I’m so happy to have found this amazing story again.
This is a really good fic. I'm a little nervous around Good!Voldemort fics because they become morally questionable at times and misconstrue personalities, but you did well. The forgiveness with Magic as the judge was interesting. I like how Tom saw Severus as a brother and that had enough effect to change his personality. Well done.
This is a really good fic. I'm a little nervous around Good!Voldemort fics because they become morally questionable at times and misconstrue personalities, but you did well. The forgiveness with Magic as the judge was interesting. I like how Tom saw Severus as a brother and that had enough effect to change his personality. Well done.
That was NOT what I was expecting.
Also, if Harry is merciless, and Petunia decent to him, would he be more Slytherin, cause honestly Petunia is hella Slytherin.
That was NOT what I was expecting.
Also, if Harry is merciless, and Petunia decent to him, would he be more Slytherin, cause honestly Petunia is hella Slytherin.
| Title: Epilogue: Nineteen Years Later
| 13 Jan 2022 2:36 am
|
| Reviewer: cavehack (Signed)
| [Report This]
|
I read this again and still find it just as compelling on the second read through!
| Title: Epilogue: Nineteen Years Later
| 01 May 2021 11:58 pm
|
| Reviewer: cavehack (Signed)
| [Report This]
|
This is a fabulous and so creatively told story.
I already left a review, back in May, but, after re-reading it, AGAIN (I can't help it: It's just that GOOD!), I do have just a couple of questions... I in no way dislike nor disagree with you deviating from canon; as a matter of fact, I prefer it, as I despise the books, as you'd know, if you'd read my 1st review. Now, what I'd like to know is: Was Sirius accused of betraying the Potters and what became of him and Remus? You opened the door, dear, with your mentioning the Marauders as Sev's tormentors at school; which, in turn, connects to the 'betrayal' in canon. I'm just curious, but otherwise: I don't question anything else!
I feel unconditional love for this story!
MelJ
OMG, I LOVE this story!! It's nearly perfect; the only thing I had a problem with is that it's much too SHORT! You could stretch this out a bit and give Rowling a run for her money, which, truth be told, wouldn't be terribly hard!
She, unlike other, truly brilliant, thoughtful, and intelligent writers (I include you in that classification) in the Fantasy genre, 'hit' at the right time; a time when there was a dearth of 'magical fantasy', as the genre had previously fallen out of vogue. I grew up reading nothing but fantasy and Science Fiction, but I had moved on to adult writers, such as McCaffrey and Orson Scott Card and, therefore, paid little or no attention to 'Juvenile Fantasy', as I found the newest practitioners, in that field, to be less and less adherents to logic and common sense and more and more into 'blindly follow your leaders' type propagandizing. Rowling is not only just the worst of that lot, but also had access to the best PR campaign ever conceived!
Anyway (I could and probably should write a treatise on all that's wrong with HP and Rowling!), THANK YOU for sharing your simply amazing talent with us and I shall treasure this story, always!
Sincerely, respectfully yours,
MelJ
| Title: Epilogue: Nineteen Years Later
| 14 Dec 2015 3:53 pm
|
| Reviewer: Twonky (Signed)
| [Report This]
|
I quite enjoyed this story! Thanks for writing it.
|