Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For Spiral of Trust
Title: Chapter 22 A Boggart to be laughed at 18 May 2015 2:47 pm
Reviewer: Buchling (Anonymous) [Report This]
    I like this story a lot and I feel the characters are well balanced and believable. However ever so often you leave things kind of unfinished; like the incompetency of the healer lady or Harrys paper published under Snapes name. There were a couple more things that I can't recall right now. I just wondered if that's simply your way of writing, most things are not completely resolved in real life after all, or if there's somekind of plan to it.

    Author's Response:

    Thanks for reviewing and for your observation about unfinished things. My answer is that I do have a plan, mostly. I have ”planted” several things that will be ”picked up” and explained later on in the story. I worry a bit, though, that the story is too slow and that you have to wait too long to get some answers and that the readers will get frustrated, or wonder, like you, if it will not lead anywhere… Maybe it is this thing with posting once a weak - maybe you would get another impression if you were to read the chapters in more rapid succession… Or maybe it is simply my inexperience as a writer - this is after all my first fanfiction story :-)  

     

    The Acromantula paper will be brought up again in exactly three chapters from now. The incompetent healer will make a reappearance later on in the story, but in her case, like you said, my point is more to show that there are, also in real life, people around, even authorities, even professionals, who are incompetent and who make bad decisions and that you simply have to deal with, in some way or other. 

     

     

    Thank you for appreciating the portrayal of the characters. I try not to make them too unidimensional. And I prefer, in this story, both Snape and Harry to be resourceful rather than helpless and broken, without acquiring that impersonal status of Super power wizards, however.


Title: Chapter 22 A Boggart to be laughed at 17 May 2015 6:52 pm
Reviewer: Anna (Anonymous) [Report This]
    I really enjoy reading this story :D!! It is just fantastic! Thanks for two new chapters! So will Harry's animagus form be known? I can just see Ritas cat cought the canary grin - more slling headlines:P;) Looking forward to much more!

    Author's Response: Thanks! Rita Skeeter is not finished yet with plaguing our heroes, alas! Much more coming any day now :-)
Title: Chapter 22 A Boggart to be laughed at 15 May 2015 9:10 pm
Reviewer: Fmh (Signed) [Report This]
    Excellent chapter and a very clever take withRita and the Prophet. Can I make a plea not too have Harry with too many super powers I love the cannon Harry with all his fallibility. Thank you again for a wonderful story.

    Author's Response:

    I see what you mean about the super powers. It’s not my intention to have a Superpower Harry in this story (I’m not particularly fond of that kind of character myself). The Animagus chapter was, I acknowledge, strictly speaking not exactly necessary for the plot, but it is hard, when you picture a scene in your head, not to indulge in writing it down and include it… I will defend myself by saying that even if Harry in this story is more studious than in canon and develops some new skills, I also try to take pains to show his shortcomings and his vulnerability. His Animagus form is a small insignificant snake, and he is very uncomfortable with it. It is interesting, in analogy with the Grief Swallower gift and in light of the accusation of parentage with Snape and Voldemort, to reflect over the powers of genetics and of environmental exposure, respectively. Harry is not genetically related to Voldemort (despite what Rita Skeeter tries to make out), but he has been exposed to the dark wizard’s influence during his lifetime and he cannot get away from that kind of heritage - he needs to learn to live with it. That was, more or less, what I was trying to imply in the chapter where Harry becomes an Animagus.


Title: Chapter 22 A Boggart to be laughed at 14 May 2015 9:55 pm
Reviewer: ohmysnape (Signed) [Report This]
    I don't know why, and it really shouldn't, but reading about Snape being in a horrid mood because of Skeeter made me laugh at points. I can just imagine him skulking about the castle, promising death to whomever gets in his way.

    God, I hate Rita Skeeter. No wonder's Sev has a permanent storm cloud above his head. What a story! Almost wish Voldemort was around to hear that one!

    Ooh, but then part about Harry being Snape's son... ooh, that must really piss off Snape, knowing that Harry COULD HAVE been his if he hadn't ruined things with Lily... eesh. Very angsty, I felt just as frustrated as Harry did by the end. Update soon!

    Author's Response:

    The funny part, I think, is that Snape has been taunting Harry about his celebrity status since Harry’s first year at Hogwarts and now Snape is forced to endure the same kind of unwelcome attention from the press that Harry has had to put up with all those years…

     

    I didn’t really know whether Skeeter’s story about Voldemort’s heir would go down well or badly - maybe it’s a bit exaggerated, but on the other hand, this is only fan fiction - a ff writer can indulge in all kind of weird ideas, right :-) ?


Title: Chapter 22 A Boggart to be laughed at 14 May 2015 6:50 pm
Reviewer: BlueWater5 (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Loved Rita's speculations.

    Author's Response: Great! I didn't know whether a plot like that would go down well or badly...
Title: Chapter 22 A Boggart to be laughed at 14 May 2015 6:04 pm
Reviewer: tb_ll57 (Anonymous) [Report This]
    I continue to enjoy Harry's maturity in this. He's grown into a young man not easily persuaded to react blindly, and his loyalty even to someone like Snape who doesn't earn it (or sometimes appear to want it even) is a very noble characteristic. I also really enjoy the small details-- that Hermione reads the paper to Harry is sweet but builds on their characters, her the voracious reader of all information, Harry trusting her to tell him the unvarnished truth but only in so far as he needs to know it. The little aside about Ron taking the high road to win arguments was funny and true to his character. And in the last chapter McGonagall's well-meaning condescenion about Harry's questions of ethics reminded me of the house elf storyline in Goblet of Fire. The wizarding world has some built-in cruelties, and Harry's question struck me less as child-like than probing reality for things that shouldn't be accepted at face value.

    So glad to have two chapters at once as well! What a treat.

    Author's Response: Thank you for noticing those small details! 

Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5