Summary: Harry suffers from elective (not selective!) mutism. It means that he is physically able to speak but does not in most situations.
Suggestions:
- Harry stops speaking after one of his many encounters with Lord Voldemort
OR
- Harry stops speaking before coming to Hogwarts, because of the abuse by the Dursleys
OR
- Harry decides to stop speaking because he doesn't feel like he'll be listened to and feels like he's being ignored in fifth year
OR
- Harry stops speaking to Snape at all but talks to everyone else, because whatever he says, Snape always warps it into something negative
[Report This]