Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For O Mine Enemy
Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 20 Aug 2007 10:04 am
Reviewer: lilseverus (Anonymous) [Report This]
    A cliffhanger?! Nooooo!

    Can't wait for when Dumbledore arrives!


    I love how the Occlumency book is so boring that Harry is rereading the same paragraph over and over again, that is how I sometimes feel about my homework..

    Author's Response:

    hehe, it'll be alright!  I promise!  I try to give occasional breaks from cliffies, but sometimes I do get in the mood... ;)

    Thanks for the review!

Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 20 Aug 2007 6:07 am
Reviewer: Branwyn (Signed) [Report This]
    That was an immensely satisfying read, it is good to see Harry at his wiliest! Snape must respect that, despite himself. I do look forward to seeing Dumbledore rake him over the coals.

    Author's Response: Thank you for the review!  I'm so glad you're enjoying the story!
Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 20 Aug 2007 5:07 am
Reviewer: xikum (Anonymous) [Report This]
    I forgot to add: I very much love the Q&A game - it really seems to help them to get to know one another, and help them develop a more positive relationship. It's fun watching Snape getting puzzled and trying to figure just what Harry was trying to do with the questions about himself and the Malfoys - though back to my ADHD supposition - Harry had wanted originally to figure stuff out about Severus and Lucius and what was up, and he distracted himself to Draco & Snape's relationship. Very interesting.

    I also adored the little quip about Snape being a Master of most things - except interpersonal relationships! LOL

    Author's Response:

    Hi again! :)  Thank you for your kind comments.  I like the Q&A game, too - it's a lot of fun to write, and I think at this point there's no way in H-E-double-broomsticks that they would confide these things to each other unless they were each getting something out of the deal. 

Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 20 Aug 2007 5:00 am
Reviewer: xikum (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Wow. Reading this was hard, and made me sad for the child - it really made me think over and again, that Harry has untreated ADHD! No matter how he tries, and he does try - he brings himself back to task, independently, over and over again!!! No matter how many times he tries toapply himself - he can barely stay on task for just a little bit before some other idea distracts him, and off he goes, down that rabbit trail. Poor kid.
    Um, is there a cure or treatment for ADHD in the wizarding world, that would allow Harry to focus, and learn - because it is clear that he is intelligent, simply distracted and impulsive.

    Author's Response:

    Are you a teacher? :)  Most of my family are teachers, and my roommate is actually a special education teacher - she works with quite a few kids with learning and attention disorders.  It was just funny to hear you refer to terms she uses all the time. ;)

    I hadn't thought of Harry as having ADHD specifically, though it's an interesting idea.  In his case I was thinking more along the lines that he has a hard time focusing on things that he doesn't see as important...like Potions and Occlumency.  He quite simply doesn't care about those subjects, and I think trying to focus on a huge jargon-filled book about a subject you don't care about would make anyone a little antsy.  (Especially with everything else on his mind.)  Hermione, on the other hand, I'm sure would be thrilled! :)

    As for a treatment...well, I'm not going the ADHD route specifically, but I'm sure a task-oriented mentor would be able to figure out a few things to help.  Hmm...where could we find such a person, I wonder? ;)  Thank you for the review!

Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 19 Aug 2007 6:06 am
Reviewer: Dino1Draco (Signed) [Report This]
    Great chapters, SO happy to come back from vacation and I have 2 chapters. Can't wait for more.

    Author's Response: Thanks for the review! And welcome back from vacation!
Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 18 Aug 2007 7:20 pm
Reviewer: Kristeh (Signed) [Report This]
    I really enjoyed this chapter! The dialogue between Harry and Snape is great.

    I love how they barter questions back and forth, it's a way for them to get to know one another without actually admitting that they want to know each other.

    I also liked how Harry pointed out that Snape really never gave him much of a chance to learn Occlumency correctly. Maybe it'll hit home with the Potions professor.

    Looking forward to the next chapter!

    Author's Response: Thanks for the review! I hope you continue to read & enjoy!
Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 18 Aug 2007 12:38 pm
Reviewer: Nicole (Signed) [Report This]
    Amusing. There finnally comes some improvement on the relationship between those two. Harry's really cute in this chapter. Update soon.

    Author's Response: Thank you for the review!  Yes, improvement is looming...slow but steady! :)
Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 18 Aug 2007 8:19 am
Reviewer: veritas427 (Signed) [Report This]
    I don't know why it is, but I always love stories where Harry tells Snape that the Sorting Hat wanted to put him in Slytherin. I really don't know why. Of course, in many cases Harry is eager to tell Snape that he could have been put in Slytherin, in order to shock him or cause Snape to reevaluate him. However, I must say that I like your version of telling Snape about Slytherin much better! I think it is much more in character of Harry to quickly defend his right to be in Gryffindor. Ha ha. Harry really should think more about what he wants to say before blurting out more information than he wants to reveal. This is Snape, of course he is going to catch on to and interpret correctly, everything that you say! lol.

    And now my two favorite parts of the chapter!
    Part one: Yes, sir,” Harry answered automatically, picking up the book. May as well quit while he was ahead. He could celebrate later that Snape had forgotten he had another turn left–

    “Oh, and Potter?” Snape interrupted his thoughts, “My round of questions shall be considered delayed, rather than forfeited. I fully intend to collect, I assure you.”

    LOVED IT!!!! Just when Harry thought that he had won the battle, and outsmarted Snape...! Perfect!

    And number two:
    “If you are in such dire need of a break, go to the laboratory and begin your puffer-fish sorting. I’ll expect you back in fifteen minutes to continue your reading.”

    “Er…no thanks. I’m at a…really good spot.”

    I started laughing incontrollably at that part! Terrific dialogue, and it was interesting to finally get some answers out of Snape! I definitely can't wait for the next chapter! Thanks for giving me a well written story to look forward to all of the time!

    Author's Response:

    I am so in LOVE with long reviews!  THANK YOU!!!

    Yes, I love Snape finding out about the sorting hat too, but I've always believed that Harry wouldn't volunteer the information willingly.  Really, I don't think Harry yet cares too much what Snape thinks of him since he doesn't respect the man's views on anything else...so volunteering the information in order to get Snape to reevaluate him isn't something I see Harry doing.  And he's proud of being a Gryffindor.  He wouldn't want to be anything else.

    So glad you liked those parts of the fic!  They were fun to write.  The most fun thing to hear from reviewers is that something in the story made them laugh.  It makes me smile...so thank you for making me smile! :)

Title: Chapter 14 - Occlumency Tutor Wanted 18 Aug 2007 8:05 am
Reviewer: veritas427 (Signed) [Report This]
    How is it that I am always behind on reviewing for your story? Oh wait...that's right...I have a summer job where I basically work every single day. Wow...I can't wait to go back to college next week, I'll actually have some free time! lol.

    First off...amazing dream sequence! Honestly... I was so caught up in the story that I didn't even bother to answer my cell phone when it rang. I don't ever not answer my phone, so consider that as a major compliment to your talented writing skills.

    I wonder when Harry will talk to Dumbledore about the second prophecy. Hmm...the plot thickens...

    Snape is amazing in this chapter as usual. Honestly, I am amazed by his wonderful skills in sarcasm. Perhaps he took a class Sarcasm 101: How to be snarky and sarcastic to everyone you meet (especially with those who annoy you)or perhaps Creative Insulting. Ha ha.

    Well I'm off to read the next chapter!

    Author's Response:

    hehe, I SO relate to the work vs. college thing! I work fulltime (plus a part-time job, plus an internet class), and I really, really miss college. I want to rewind...because the great thing about college is that even though you're busy, your time is your own - YOU get to decide whether to study now or later...or even to not study at all! *sigh* Can I come with you?  I especially want to take that Sarcasm 101 class - it sounds like fun!!

    Oh, please make your apologies to whomever was calling you.  (But I'm really not sorry - it thrills me that you were that into the story.)  And keep reading...the plot shall continue to thicken... :)

Title: Chapter 15 - An Experiment in Civility 18 Aug 2007 2:04 am
Reviewer: bluebird88 (Signed) [Report This]
    Another amusing chapter! I do love Snape's oh-so-succinct answers, especially in contrast to Harry's tendency to ramble. "How well do you know the Malfoys?" "Well." Fantastic! I can just *feel* Harry's frustration trying to get any information at all out of the man. The out-of-the blue "legilimency" was priceless!

    I love how Snape seems to be a bit amused at Harry's attempts at being Slytherin, and Harry wondering if Snape was Draco's Sirius was a cute touch.

    Author's Response: Thank you for the review, bluebird88!  I'm glad you liked it - those bits you commented on were so fun to write! :)

Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5