Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For The Poor of God
Title: Please Respond 12 Sep 2007 11:02 am
Reviewer: Kirby Lane (Signed) [Report This]
    HOW much did I love the shoe shrinking?

    THIS :) :) :) :) :) :) :) :) :) MUCH!

    So sweet!
Title: Return to Sender 12 Sep 2007 10:31 am
Reviewer: Kirby Lane (Signed) [Report This]
    I appreciate your talent for dialogue. Thank you for not simply plopping words on a page, as many fanfic writers tend to do. You don't just write Snape and Harry; you direct them like you would direct a play: I can imagine their movements and facial expressions, and I not only believe their thoughts - I find myself caught up in them. I just had to say - nice work. :)

    Favorite line:

    "But they don't look happy to see us."

    "Don't they?" says Luna. "I think they look rather pleased, myself."

    hehe - gotta love that Luna.

    Oh, but then there is the exchange between the trio about Snape being "twitchy," aka protective. I loved that too.

    You mentioned several times in this chapter how Snape is becoming very parental and protective of Harry. I like it; parental, protective Snape makes me go 'awww' and want to give him a great big hug. But even though I'm getting all soppy, I like that Harry isn't completely embracing it right away. He needs it and you can tell he wants it whether he admits it or not, but he's just indignant enough to still be Harry.

    Oh, and the exchange between them in the hall after the confrontation was nice, too.

    Can you tell I loved this chapter? :)

    Now excuse me while I run off to tell you how much I loved the shoe shrinking from the last chapter...

    Author's Response:

    Everyone sees Snape turning into the world's most unlikely overprotective mentor towards Harry. Except Snape and Harry. Cause they're like that.

    And yay, I'm glad Luna's line made you laugh. I never know whether people are going to laugh when I do or not! 

Title: Return to Sender 12 Sep 2007 9:57 am
Reviewer: Trekker2002 (Signed) [Report This]
    A new chapter. Yippee. (My hands were starting to shake... I'm not addicted you understand.I can stop anytime I want...I just don't want to).

    Good chapter, a bit lighter on the emotional wringer,(thank goodness, I couldn't take much more) at least until the attack.

    But the tension is building again.

    What it the mark on Snape's sleeve?
    What's in the letter?
    Will Luna be okay?
    What spell has Harry been hit by and what will it do to him?
    How on earth will Snape deal with his Slytherins and still preserve his cover?

    Why is the pleasure of reading the chapter so quickly dissolving into anticipation of the next wait? ARRRGGH

    One part of me is sceaming 'WRITE FASTER' but the rational bit admits that you do have to sleep and eat sometimes.

    A huge THANKYOU for the story so far. Off now for a re-read.

    Author's Response:

    The mark on Snape's sleeve is Harry's blood from Vernon's attack---what with one thing and another he hasn't changed his shirt in over 24 hours.

    If by "the letter" you mean the one Harry wrote, you'll find out in detail soon.

    Luna will live. That's all I promise.

    Harry hasn't been hit by anything more than the Sectumsempra to his face that Snape healed, but Luna fell back into him and he hit the ground hard. Between that and the running, he's done his ribs no good.

    Snape is...infinitely creative. 

Title: Return to Sender 12 Sep 2007 9:22 am
Reviewer: jharad17 (Signed) [Report This]
    Ooohhhhh, nail biter of a chapter there. Poor Luna! Poor Harry! And poor Snape, to have to see them both in pain . . . Oh, and I can't wait to see what Harry wrote to Vernon! I do hope it was appropriate. :-)

    Author's Response: It's more a question of Snape will MAKE him do to Vernon...
Title: Return to Sender 12 Sep 2007 9:14 am
Reviewer: Alexis8907 (Signed) [Report This]
    Stupid Harry! What happened to his reflexes? He just seems to stand there rather than do anything! I hope Luna's going to be alright and pretty please update again soon!

    Author's Response: There's nothing wrong with Harry's reflexes! It just happened really really fast, and Luna was already on her guard and prepared to protect Harry from his uncle if necessary, so it was easier for her to jump right into the fray. Harry was too busy trying to talk her into running away from danger to make the first movie.
Title: Return to Sender 12 Sep 2007 8:41 am
Reviewer: KimSpiritTalks (Signed) [Report This]
    Great Snape scenes in this chapter. And I can't wait for the conversation over Harry's "appropriate" response. I hope he gives that uncle of his a really appropriate response followed by the letter blowing up in a shower of painful hexes! Oh, sorry, lost my cool for a moment. So, 48 hours?

    Author's Response: HOPEFULLY 48 hours. No guarantees. :)
Title: Return to Sender 12 Sep 2007 8:39 am
Reviewer: cathyrf (Signed) [Report This]
    Wow! Where do I begin after reading THIS?

    (I did the Snoopy dance when I saw a new chapter listed. What can I say...I'm addicted to this story).

    I enjoyed reading it from the the very start, but thought how it was seeming "slower" than other chapters. Even Dumbledore's scolding of Snape didn't have the punch I thought I was going to see. Though I truely loved the looks that were exchanged between Harry and Snape.

    (That's because Branwyn was waiting to give me the 1-2-3 KO...I should have known...). ;-)

    When Harry made his comment to Snape about hanging him by the ankles, I spoke out loud (rare for me when reading a story) NO HARRY!! WHY DID YOU GO AND SAY THAT!! I really wanted to smack the snot out of him. But I forgave him immediately when he explained his comment to Snape. I still love you, Harry.

    I can't wait to see what reply Harry has penned to Vernon and how THAT conversation with Snape is going to go. I think that assignment from Snape was quite fun.

    Luna showing up and taking Harry to dinner? AWWWW....how adorable is that (we love Luna at our house). And Luna's comment about Snape acting like a parent just gave me the warm fuzzies I always find in this story. Just love these two characters together.

    I'm thinking....okay....they are heading to dinner? What can happen? I felt pretty confident they wouldn't be meeting Vernon so soon after the last encounter (but I'm sure he'll figure in there somewhere later). I'm thinking how cute it is that they are going to the Great Hall together and them WHAM! Branwyn writes this amazing battle with Harry and Luna and Slytherins and my heart's in my throat for Luna, and the whole thing left me breathless. I have this whole rollercoaster of emotions flying and I'm just glad my glass of Chardonnay is sitting keeping me company. Yikes!

    (Darn that Branwyn...how does she keep catching me off guard like this???)

    Snape making Harry turn his head as a matter of modesty. Loved that.

    I just knew after all this Harry has probably doomed that rib to never healing right. Luna AND Harry recooperating in Snape's quarters together? This will make for some fun darn reading soon.

    Poor Harry...he's feeling guilty AGAIN. I just need to hug that guy.

    I need to go refill my wine glass now after THAT chapter.
Title: Please Respond 12 Sep 2007 7:35 am
Reviewer: xikum (Signed) [Report This]
    I'm all smiles now!!! o great to see Harry and Severus are coming to an understanding, even though it is in it's infancy, it is a much-needed change in tone. Severus is so right, about Harry needing to develop some trust in those who are to take care of him - as well, that he finally has caretakers who are themselves, good and reasonable! I am happy that both Severus and Dumbledore are taking part now, recognizing how deep Harry's need truly is - and are stepping up to take the responsibility - even if the actual day-to-day care appears to be relegated to Severus.

    Excellent chapter!!
Title: Handle With Care 12 Sep 2007 6:54 am
Reviewer: xikum (Signed) [Report This]
    Poor Harry - learned helplessness! How are they going to fix that?
    And Snape - so sad, yet so very realistic, and he is being so very honest in his acceptance - his recognition of what is going on. BUt, oh, , how I wish that they can work it out, because relly, thow two could help each other so very much, could be so dear to one another.
    I sure hope Dumbledore has some very good ways to deal with Vernon - perhaps, feed his mind with the pain and anguish that creep has dealt to Harry, all his time with the Dursleys?
Title: For Your Immediate Attention 12 Sep 2007 6:29 am
Reviewer: xikum (Signed) [Report This]
    By all the Gods! Vernon is actually both evil and insane, that he would try to / actually attempt to kill Harry, after all he has been warned and shown. He really Does Need to Die. Hs is not doing any good to the world, and in fact, a lot of evil, both with what we know he has done to Harry, and what he has taught his son to be. Wonder how many other children have been harmed, through that? If there is any hope for Petunia or Dudley, Vernon Needs to be dispatched... in a way that makes them re-evaluate their values.
    Snape showed more self-control than I could have, coming upon Vernon in the act of killing Harry - because that is exactly what he was in process of doing!
    If there is any justice in this, Vernon has gotten many times more than his full share of warnings - and he never acted with any civility or humanity to begin with - for Justice' sake --- take him out!

Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5