Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For Lily's Charm
Title: Chapter 18: Progress 02 Mar 2008 7:08 am
Reviewer: Scorpia (Signed) [Report This]
    Great chappter I really liked it!

    Author's Response: Thanks!
Title: Chapter 44: Desperate Times 02 Mar 2008 6:54 am
Reviewer: JolisGSD (Signed) [Report This]
    Good chapter.

    I liked the interaction between Harry and Severus. Harry seems much more comfortable with Severus and willing to let Severus be his dad.

    I'm not sure what's happening with Draco and Moody. Did you previously tell us what Moody's role was and I've just forgotten? or will all be revealed in later chapters?

    The plot is thickening . . .

    Author's Response:

    The order members have sorta been guarding Draco for awhile now.  ANd Moody doesn't like Draco and really just thinks it will be easier for him to get something on him and send him away instead of dealing with his antics.  He has no other role really.  Just a order member who's tired of babysitting and doesn't think the Malfoys should be trusted. 

    Harry is definitely content with Severus as his dad.  He's proved himself enough at this point.  

    Yes, the plot is thickening a bit.  Glad you enjoyed!  Thanks for reviewing! 

Title: Chapter 44: Desperate Times 02 Mar 2008 6:38 am
Reviewer: cathyrf (Signed) [Report This]
    You know, I always have this little count I keep going in my head of how many “Oh’s!” a particular chapter gets. The funniest part is I actually say them out loud, and thankfully the members of my household know I’m rather batty so nobody questions this silly trait of mine.

    This chapter started out with “Oh!” I mean, how could it not when the tagline under the chapter title is “well, you all know what desperate times call for.“ A gulp followed the “Oh.“

    Then, the first two words are “Harry Snape!” (“Oh” number two). I had absolutely no frickin’ idea where this chapter was going. It became obvious and I slapped my head with the famous “Doh” motion because somewhere there was mention of going back and enjoying some happy baby Harry memories. I’m just not the smartest cookie in the box and I never think of those things ahead of time.

    And how adorable is baby Harry with floo powder all over him? So we now know why the floo powder box didn’t open for Harry because Lily applied a “anti Wizard Baby safety charm” on it (probably purchased at the local Wizard Babies R Us branch) being the great mother she is and all. And Severus is the good daddy and plays distraction with a new bauble after Harry loses his first. AND Severus takes little Harry for his first broom flight. Love it, love it, love it.

    Remus was certainly closemouthed with all Harry’s questions. And Harry tried his darndest to get answers, but Remus was only answering in as few words as possible.

    Then “Oh” number three came up when Severus answers out of nowhere and shocks Harry with “I am not in denial.” Heck, he startled me. And how hard it seemed for Severus to give James’ things to Remus. We all know, although he doesn’t outwardly show it, how much he thought of James.

    The next “Oh” (is that four?) came when he demanded Harry give his word about following his instructions without question when he admitted trying to use the floo to get back. I kind of felt like his eyes were staring at ME too and not just Harry he was so damned serious. *brrrrr*

    The “awwwws” were for all the touching moments Harry and Severus got to share in that box, from the “Hi Daddy” picture, which gave me a lump in my throat, to the Severus covered in orange. It’s nice to see Severus almost smile at the memories. And they got to see his baby room and Lily’s ring. How bittersweet.

    Wait, onto “Oh” number five - that is when Severus starts to question Harry about his scar hurting when he was near the locket. And that got me wondering if the part of Voldemort’s soul in the locket was recognizing the part of the soul contained within Harry. Hmmmm……

    I adored Harry’s chatting with all the little Sytherins and his talk with his father about changing his last name. Severus said he’d look into it. And I find it so funny how his voice keeps popping up in Harry’s head such as “wear your coat.” Truly, ROTFL. Wish I could do that to MY kids.

    And Filch being picked up and moved around Severus and Harry. Oh that Dumbledore…his sense of humor is too wicked!

    But yikes! Malfoy starts his angry rant at our boys and I did the next “Oh” for the night. And Harry spoke up for him…that’s our noble Gryffindor for you! But drop some Veritaserum down that boys’ throat because I don’t know whether to believe him or not that he was not going to go all the way in murdering Dumbles. Severus must keep some of that around somewhere…

    Thank you, OE, for keeping Sev’s patronus in line with the books, because I loved that he took Lily’s patronus. It was so sweet and tragic and romantic and I appreciate it staying as his. (But who did he call??)

    Who gets this chapter’s hug? Tonight, it’s for ObsidianEmbrace for keeping me so thoroughly entertained with her amazing story. This is for you, girlfriend! {{{{HUGS}}}}

    Author's Response:

    YAY!  I got a hug!  *happy dance*

    You did have a lot of "oh" moments this time. LOL  

    Sev does sorta get a daddy award with this little happy Harry moments in 1981, doesn't he?  Awww.

    Well, Remus is trying really hard not to step on toes, knowing that he is sorta in limbo with Severus, not quite friends and he doesnt know if Sev wants this stuff answered....  Poor Remus.  

    Yeah, Sev startled Harry as well.  Doh!  And yeah, he was pretty serious and though Harry's means his promise now, is he really going to be able to keep it.  Gryffindors and their honor, though.... 

     There were a lot of bittersweet moments, weren't there?  So much sadness really just permeated this chapter.  I'mkind of a depressed. :oP

    I love your speculation about the locket...but more than that...sorry, that's all I can say about that.  LOL

    Yeah, Sev is really enjoying their little mind reading.  Hee hee.  Let's see how he likes it though once Harry learns how to do it.  ROFL

    Dumbledore is pretty funny but he did promise Sev that Filch woudln't go near Harry.  LOL

    Yay for Harry sticking up for Draco...did you notice he actually called him Draco?  Hmm...intriguing.  Everyone's just getting all close, aren't they?  LOL   Well, you'll just have to wait and see what Draco was gonna be up to.

    Sev's patronus is very much the same, though I have my own reasonings as to why.  See PK's review for a complete explanation!  You'll have to wait and see who he called though. Sorry.

    Thanks so much for the review and just for everything! :o) 

     

Title: Chapter 17: A Different Approach 02 Mar 2008 6:26 am
Reviewer: Scorpia (Signed) [Report This]
    Good boy Snape! Lol, The Olculemecy lesson was great to read about! I enjoyed this chapter very much!

    Author's Response: So glad!  I love those Occlumency scenes.  They are really fun!
Title: Chapter 16: Help 02 Mar 2008 6:13 am
Reviewer: Scorpia (Signed) [Report This]
    Severus is so sweet being worried about Harry! :) I wonder how he will react to Ginny being Harry's girlfriend though? OoO! Lol, I can't wait.
    Scorpia

    Author's Response: LOL  Sev has his issues with Ginny and Harry but no more will I say.  :oP
Title: Chapter 15: Dark Mark 02 Mar 2008 5:59 am
Reviewer: Scorpia (Signed) [Report This]
    Another great chapter! I liked how Luscious isn't really a bad guy like he is in SO many other stories! Oooh! The first HarryGinny moment. :)

    Author's Response: Yay for Harry and Ginny!  Lucius is unique.  That's all I'll say about that.  LOL
Title: Chapter 14: Nudges from Remus 02 Mar 2008 5:46 am
Reviewer: Scorpia (Signed) [Report This]
    Oh Man, when I read this chapter I was transported out of my yellow bedroom and I forgot about wanting to kill the neighbors dog because it hasn't shut up in the longest, and suddenly I was in the dark and dreary potions classroom. Giggling madly at Harry's expense with Draco Malfoy! (He's so cute) Blushing for Harry, and smiling at the perfect end! This was eithier one of the best chapters ever or I've finally gone insane. I'm hoping for the first one, Lol.
    Scorpia

    Author's Response: LOL  Glad you liked it!  I do have to agree that's it's just the best chapter ever choice.  Hee hee.   LOL  I love that you're laughing at Harry.  That's funny! 
Title: Chapter 44: Desperate Times 02 Mar 2008 5:35 am
Reviewer: pkrosche (Signed) [Report This]
    Wow. You truly do have everything going on in this one...and I said I'd give you a long review, so here goes...

    This 1981 scene was just precious! I can't believe how at ease Sev is around Lily, Harry, and especially James. It was heart wrenching to read, knowing their horrible fates. But, Sev really got to me, needing to show off in front of his wife and to show up James...despite his distaste of heights and the fact that brooms evoke "childish" behavior...it was the perfect scene. *giddy*

    I do wonder how floo powder tastes...not good I suppose.

    And finally, Harry starts asking those all-important questions. Good job, Harry! You really did put a lot of thought into plotting this whole story out, didn't you? I don't remember what that chapter was but I do remember asking you over and over again what Tonks and Moody were doing in Gringotts...and now we know! Did they have as much trouble as Ron, Harry, and Hermione did or was it in a more accessible spot? I'm just glad they're ok from that experience...

    If only I could say the same for Remus...what happened to him?!?! He better get over his uncomfortableness real soon!

    I do love how he still keeps his wits about him, that Remus. Saying that Harry needs to listen to his father first and foremost before himself was awesome of Remus...love that werewolf...even if he is a bit of a sissy.

    And with Harry's next line, my heart was squashed below someone's shoe...and was horridly jumped on with Sev's entering line... These boys have simply endured too much pain. It's truly heartbreaking. *depressed*

    And the poor remnants of my heart were subjected to a far worse beating as the conversation continued. I do wonder, though, was it hurt that Harry felt coming from his father at Remus' question of, "Are you sure you don't want them, Severus?" And what was going on between Sev and Remus as Harry sat looking at them, neither of them answering...

    Tee hee...floo box...

    Question, why would Sev have to sleep in what I can only imagine as being the spare bedroom with the rollaway bed? Why couldn't he stay with Lily? Besides, they were there only once with Harry...so there would have been no fake marriage between James and Lily and no one should have been able to find it anyway. Right?

    I do love how the connection between Harry and Sev plays a part in their conversations...a LARGE part. It's great just because now Harry can say the right things once and a while now too.

    It must have been extremely hard for Harry to even consider answering Sev's request to obey him...but, alas, he did. I just hope that Sev realizes that Harry can't always be expected to do so, just because he promised.

    I love, love, loved the little trip down memory lane these two took, hand in hand, skipping along to a happy tune! It was beautiful, sad, funny, adorable, and heart wrenching. Thanks, I bow down to you and your masterful abilities.

    Carrots...this was defiantly the best picture of the lot...

    Hmmm...how did Albus 'save' Lily's ring...hmmm indeed... Is there any more to know about this particular plot point?

    And poor, poor Severus... My heart felt another painful stab when he said that he didn't get past Filius' book. *almost crying now...heart in shreds on the ground*

    And then it was lifted above my head as Harry and Sev went to tour the upstairs bedrooms...until it came crashing back down, taking my stomach with it. A definite low...I still do think that Sev is just saying that it's not Harry's fault to protect his feelings...and I really hate thinking that. But it just doesn't seem reasonable for there to be a DE meeting and two days later, mere hours after their encounter with the horcrux, for there to be another...especially since Lucius was tortured at the last one. *sigh* I just don't know...

    ...especially since Harry's scar didn't begin to hurt until after Dumbledore took the locket...

    *now trying to piece back my heart which was thoroughly ground into the carpet* Yay for brewing and mental connections! And Slytherins!! I love that Jones girl...her older brother was in my year.

    I do love Harry's concern for his father's welfare. Those Slytherins have proven they can be nasty and I hope everything's going as well as Sev says it is...not that I doubt him...much. And Harry's right...there has been a great change that can be seen within both of them. They truly have come a long way and though it's been hard, they've both made it through together. *heart floats again*

    And I loved Ms. Jones' little chat about Harry's name. Hopefully next chapter there will be an unexpected visitor to their dungeon apartment, with some particular documents for Harry and Sev to sign...

    Filch...and good thinking, Dumbledore!

    ...although, I would have enjoyed watching Sev punch him!

    And that line! Cathy, you deserve a big hug! I loved it!! Finally! Some other house gets weaseled out of Harry other than Hufflepuff!! Ha ha!

    And then my heart goes back into the carpet...with Draco.

    I hadn't realized how close to the end I was until I was there...and this part with Draco made me not want it to end...I just feel so sorry for him...but he's got to realize that there ARE people there at Hogwarts that can help him, that he doesn't have to be handling this on his own. Hopefully Harry'll be able to get to him sooner or later. *tries to pick out pieces of shattered heart from the carpet*

    And Moody certainly isn't helping matters...

    But I've got to hand it to Harry for sticking up for Draco. He did an amazing job and I think he said exactly what needed to be said, which was the truth, in support of Draco. And good for Draco for keeping his mouth shut too...or has he taken Harry's words to heart?

    Hmm...I can only assume that Sev called for Dumbledore, but can you tell us what Harry was going to ask his father in reference to his Patronus? Because I didn't think that Harry knew Lily's Patronus was a doe.

    Poor, poor Draco. I hope he finds more security in the upcoming chapters...

    Well, now that my heart is hopefully back where it's supposed to be, I must once again bow to your awesomeness. And thank you for the end note mention...I didn't realize that I was nudging. But, I'm glad it did the trick, too!

    So, how's that next chapter coming along? It better be a long one...I think Harry's got some questions he wants answered...or maybe just I do...

    Good luck with the next chapter and enjoy the remainder of your weekend!

    Author's Response:

    Sev is truly at ease around all of these people…his little family…yep, even James by now.  It does make it all the more sadder though, doesn’t it?  Such a tragedy.  It really is.  I love that you saw Sev trying to show off.  LOL  He’s a funny one, isn’t he?  LOL

     

    LOL  Yes, I did spent a bit of time thinking of a plot.  LOL, PK!  You’re funny.  Nope, Tonks and Moody didn’t have too much trouble.  Hee hee.

    Remus hmmm….well, you’ll just have to use your imagination for that one, for now.  LOL  And, he’s not a sissy.  How dare you!  :oP   

    I am sorry to have wrenched so many emotions from you…but nah, not really.  These boys have truly been through too much, haven’t they?  Poor guys.

    Hurt, maybe…so many emotions really.  It’s complicated.  I think Sev is finally realizing that Remus just might be suitable for a friend and that is hard to take.  Just like it was hard to take when it was James.  And jealousy as well that perhaps he thinks Lupin was a better friend to James and sadness.  Sev is famous for that.  He’s confused, what can I say?

    Glad you liked that Floo Box.

    The rollaway bed was in the Potions lab. Harry was referring back to the time when Severus stayed at the safe house after Lily died.  He needed somewhere safe to stay but he wouldn’t have been able to bring himself to go upstairs, so he pretty much lived in the lab with his sad little bed until Albus made him move to Hogwarts.  Is your heart breaking even more now?  *sniffle*

    Harry can say the right things now.  Hee hee.  Funny what a little mind reading will do.  LOL

    Well, Harry does mean his promise, right now anyways.  LOL  He always intends to be good, doesn’t he?  LOL

    You’re so funny.  I’m so glad you enjoyed the memories and I knew you’d enjoy the pictures.  You always do. 

    Albus didn’t really save the ring but he went to the house after Lily and James had died and salvaged what could be salvaged.  He boxed it all up.  Lily’s ring just happened to come along.  But yes, it will come back later…but not for a very, very long time….

    Sev wasn’t lying about anything to do with Voldemort…he’s got much to consider, however.  That much I will tell you.  Don’t be sad. Sev is being a good dad, I promise.

    There has been a change…all is right with the world.  Well, okay not at all but yeah, at least they have each other. 

    Harry Snape will be back.  Never fear!

    Hee hee.  Yes, very good thinking Dumbles.  LOL  PK!  I don’t think Sev punching Filch would be a very good example… *shakes head*

    LOL  Yes, Harry’s got all the houses in him…well not Ravenclaw yet.  Hm….I’ll have to work on that. 
     
    Yes, someone help Draco!  He needs it.  He really does. 

    Yeah, I am not fond of Moody.  He stinks!

    I told you you’d be proud of dear Harry.  Go Harry!

    Harry was making a connection there with the Patronus as he knows his is a stag because of James.  My take here is that there is some sort of magical intertwining that happens with people’s love.  Lily is a doe because she has a gentle, wise nature and she draws attention just because of who she is, much like the doe.  James, always attracted to Lily becomes a Stag as an Animagus in response to that (though he’s not consciously aware…it’s in the magic).  And Snape’s Patronus is a doe, same as Lily’s because his love is a different kind of love.  A purer love that makes them soul mater or whatever the magical equivalent.  Whereas James would be a stag because he’s more showoffy, trying to get attention, bravado for Lily, where Sev is much quieter with his attentions.  So, anyways, Harry was wondering about the connection between the doe and the stag since they do seem to go together….  Makes you wonder if Harry’s Patronus will stay the same now…remember how Tonks’ changed in book 6  (wiggles eyebrows mysteriously).


    Poor, poor Draco. I hope he finds more security in the upcoming chapters...

    You are on of my most important nudgers and that my friend, is a very good thing!  So, thanks!

     

    Sheesh, I am working on 45!  Yikes, I better get busy!  :o)

Title: Chapter 44: Desperate Times 02 Mar 2008 5:34 am
Reviewer: Jade_Sullivan (Signed) [Report This]
    A terrific chapter! I loved the scene with Harry and Sev and the floo powder. That was adorable. You write a baby Harry very well and believable. I usually have a hard time with baby fics, because the baby babble annoys me, but this was absolutely perfect. I'm glad you got a jolt of inspiration and posted this. It was really a great chapter. The last scene with Malfoy was interesting...I actually like this version better than the original 'chat' between Severus and Draco. This conversation seemed to have more depth and revealed the relationship between the two. So, awesome job with that :)

    Keep going with this; I promise, it's fabulous.

    I was attacked with the stomach flu over the weekend, but I'm still planning on posting SfS tomorrow if it kills me...lol.

    Anyway, thanks for the update! You're quite the brilliant one, I'd say... *hugs*

    Author's Response:

    Oh, Jade.  You are too wonderful.  *grins excitedly*  Thanks so much for reviewing and I must say, before I say one more word that I am giddy just thinking about SFS!  Keep typing, Jade!  I'm glad you liked the baby part.  I modeled baby Harry after my son.  LOL 

    Malfoy has issues, it's true!  I'm so happy you enjoyed this Sev and Draco conversation.  Draco is really hurted and really Sev is too, for so many reasons.  Heck, they all need a big hug!

    Thanks again.  I really appreciate all your kind words!  Yay!  Now, go type.  I need my Sirius fix!  :oP 

Title: Chapter 13: Vigil 02 Mar 2008 5:25 am
Reviewer: Scorpia (Signed) [Report This]
    I loved the first scene with Harry & Snapey. Snape seemed so fatherly and it was cool that Harry could reconized him by his smell. Clove's--hmmm...I want some Apple cider now! Lol, :)
    The last fighting scene between Harry & Snape at first I thought it was going to be all sweet & maybe that would hug in the end? But NO! They strarted to scream at each other! Just like boys! Lol, I was looking forward to seeing what Snape would say after Harry told him that He reconized Snape by his smell, but that didn't happen, sigh.
    Great chapter though!
    Scorpia

    Author's Response:

    LOL  Screaming at each other indeed.  They end up doing that a lot.  LOL

    I don't think Snape would have appreciated being found out by his smell.  LOL

    Thanks, though.  Glad you enjoyed it.  Cloves, screaming and all!  :oP 


Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5