Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Title: Chapter 6: Muggle Meets Magical 11 Nov 2008 10:43 pm
Reviewer: sandfull_a (Anonymous) [Report This]
    About "wanting some action"... I don't remember exactly what I meant at that point, but I surely do remember that I don't just "tolerate" the story - I like it!! So disregard my earlier message please, and I am looking forward to your next update (I think that was the general idea behind my last review).
Title: Chapter 6: Muggle Meets Magical 08 Nov 2008 3:07 am
Reviewer: Pellegrina (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Well , I really like the story so far - but it looks like it will be a loooooooooooong way until Severus and Erin will have a chance together and Harry a guardian - right now they are all like cats and dogs... Your Snape is very much in character, as are the rest of the lot! I'm looking forward to reading more of this story - thanx for sharing!

    Author's Response:

    You're welcome. Glad you are enjoying it. It will be a while before Sev and Erin get a chance to be together, but there will be a lot of UST floating around in the air. It will be even longe before Harry and Sev come to any kind of an understanding. Hope you can tolerate the wait.

    Lesley

Title: Chapter 1: Angels Do Exist. 07 Nov 2008 5:16 pm
Reviewer: sandfull_a (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Still like it. Thank you. May I propose a little bit of action? And Erin is still the most alive character I think - that's remarkable for OC!

    Author's Response:

    Not sure what you mean by a little bit of action. Sorry if it's not moving fast enough for you. And as I am now working on chapter 27, there is not a lot i can do about changing things.

    Hope you can tolerate it as is.

    Lesley

Title: Chapter 5: Flight from Reality? 07 Nov 2008 8:35 am
Reviewer: trust severus spy (Signed) [Report This]
    Okay. You have REALLY pulled me into this story! I am really loving what you're doing here. Keep on keepin' on!

    Author's Response:

    So, you like this better than A Shocking Discovery, do you. Interesting. I have a few people who have said that, but most, I think, prefer ASD. Certainly by the number of hits and reviews on fanfic ASD comes out way in front.

    Hope you keep reading both stories, and thanks for the reviews.

    Lesley

Title: Chapter 2: Harry's Champion 07 Nov 2008 7:28 am
Reviewer: trust severus spy (Signed) [Report This]
    So far, I think this is the best work of yours I've read. Your plotting is interesting, Erin seems like a real person, and you've captured Harry and the Dursleys very well.
Title: Chapter 6: Muggle Meets Magical 07 Nov 2008 1:57 am
Reviewer: Pandora (Signed) [Report This]
    Hey...I'm just curious. Will you also update on ffnet, or will you wait till this one catches up to the other one--cause I'm itching for an update of the other one!
    :)

    You know I love this story, right? ;)

    Author's Response:

    I've updated both Muggle and ASD since I started uploading this here, Dawn. So, no I am not waiting to catch up. Thanks for re-reading...or did you?

    Lesley

Title: Chapter 5: Flight from Reality? 05 Nov 2008 8:29 am
Reviewer: Anon (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Pumpkin survived too, right? (Pleads on bended knee for you not to have killed off the poor sweet kitty-cat)
    Same for Hedwig?

    Author's Response:

    Hmm, always amazes me how people care more for the animals than they do the people. I will not say yay or nay, here, but keep reading. Won't be long until you know Pumpkin and Hedwig's fate. Oh, by the way, I love animals too.

    Thank you for your review.

    Lesley

Title: Chapter 4: Muggle Vs Wizards 02 Nov 2008 1:12 pm
Reviewer: mangoyummy@hotmail.com (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Hola, it's me again. I really think some of the lines in this story are *hilarious*. But along with my praise I would like to offer you some constructive criticism! People need to stop telling Erin that she's pretty. People don't really say things like: "It is obvious from the looks of confusion and disbelief that compete for space on your very lovely, but highly expressive face." We get it. It comes across as a little Sue-ish. ;) But otherwise, this story just rawks! So funny.

    Author's Response:

    Thanks again for another review. But I have to disagree with you I am afraid. SOME people do say things like that, particularly old, gallant men who can still appreciate a pretty face. But I will watch my use of that sort of thing in the future. A young person probably wouldn't compliment soemone else even if they were strung up by their thumbs, but someone as old fashioned as DD would. As I have twenty six chapters written, I am not sure that you won't see DD being gallant again.

    And Sue-ish, well, I am afraid this, and other similar terms connected with fanfic have always seemed exceedingly stupid to me. Why would an author write an OC who is supposed to be a love interest and give her no personality and no looks. My knowledge of the term is that an author creates a person that he or she would wish themselves to be. Am I right? Or someone who seems too good to be true. I am 56 years old and I assure you, I do not want to be Erin. And yes, I have made Erin attractive, but she isn't a super model and she is by no means perfect. She has a temper to rival Sev's.

    Is a published author ever accused of having created a Mary-Sue? JK Rowling has said that Hermione is a little like she was when she was a child, does that make Hermione a Mary Sue?

    Glad you think some of the lines funny. I do try.

    Hope to hear from you again.

    Lesley

Title: Chapter 2: Harry's Champion 02 Nov 2008 11:43 am
Reviewer: mangoyummy@hotmail.com (Anonymous) [Report This]
    You're really a very talented writer. :) You have a way with words.... the only improvements I would suggest would be the choppiness in your writing when you describe people's physical appearances. But your description of feelings etc. is very nice. :)

    Author's Response:

    Thank you for your review. I will have to check some of my descriptions and try to se how they differ from the rest of my writing, but thank you for pointing out what you consider to be a fault. Even if I can figure out what you mean, I might not be able to improve because I already put my all into my writing.

    Anyway, hope it doesn't deter you from reading more.

    Lesley

Title: Chapter 5: Flight from Reality? 01 Nov 2008 6:32 pm
Reviewer: sandfull_a (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Still enjoying. And to say the truth I enjoy it even more reading long chapters. But you may have a point saying that long chapters are a little bit intimidating for some people (not for me, definitely!). So if you think its necessary, feel free to shorten the chapters a little - just not much, because if long chapters MAY be intimidating for some confused readers, very short ones are just irritating (smiles)!
    My congratulations on writing a believable "Muggle in Hogwarts" scene - its a rarity in our world.

    Author's Response:

    Thank you sandfull_a, for still reading and your review. I am like you, I love reading the long chapter too, particularly with the WIPs because you never know when you will get an update. To tell the truth I was thinking of cutting the chaters down a bit, but I wouldn't be comfortable with anything much under 4,500 words and I rarely have a chapter long enough to cut in half. So I will probably leave it as is. At least you like it!

    Probably not enough Harry and Snape interaction in this one either...the chapter where there was got the most reviews. Plus, people do not like OCs.

    Thanks for the kind words. I tried really hard to make Erin's reaction believable. Can you just imagine waking up there and seeing the things she is seeing...you would keep thinking it had to be a bad dream.

    Cheers,

    Lesley


Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5