Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For Broken Wings
Title: Hawk For Dinner 06 May 2009 5:41 pm
Reviewer: wrappedinharry (Signed) [Report This]
    I would say that a few people might have indigestion after that memorable dinner. I wonder if Umbridge herself might be the catalyst that has Harry's memory returning.

    Your time line is quite different here but then so are a lot of things. In canon, Umbridge became High Inquisitor before Christmas. And nor has Harry had any disturbing visions as he did in canon. I take it that the attack on Arthur Weasley did not happen? That this is an entirely AU fifth year.

    Enjoyable chapter. It's so nice to see Umbridge bested. Detestable woman!

    Lesley~

    Author's Response:

    I would have to agree.  It was certainly not the usual kind of thing.  As for a catalyst, you'll see what finally triggers Harry's memories.

    yes, my time line is altered greatly. I've moved things around to fit my plotline.  The visions will occur, just later on.  Yes, the snake attack did happen, some things are the same, other things are different. I use canon when and where it fits with my story, but most things are explained eventually.

    I really hate Umbridge and I had fun doing terrible things to her. 

    Thank you!

Title: Freedom's Flight 06 May 2009 2:31 pm
Reviewer: wrappedinharry (Signed) [Report This]
    Freedom's flight was wonderful. Lovely descriptions. Freedom is as good with the lure as HArry is with the snitch. I doubt Harry will ever be content on a broom again though.

    Lesley~

    Author's Response: Thank you, I loved writing this  part, since I adore watching hawks flying.  After this, no, nothing can compare with being a hawk and really flying.  He'll know the difference immediately.
Title: The Best Medicine 06 May 2009 12:55 pm
Reviewer: wrappedinharry (Signed) [Report This]
    Hmm, is there a staff member at Hogwarts who likes DD I wonder? Certainly Poppy doesn't. And what would she know of the war anyway. It's all very well to preach. Oh, I know, I know, she only cares for her patients. I hope Albus never gets sick. She'll bump him off for the greater good of Harry and Severus!

    Concerning some earlier musings of Sev's about DD'd past...how would he know anything about DD's earlier life. If you have made it the same as canon, no-one knows about DD's past, except for perhaps Elphias Doge, and he only knows what DD allowed him to know. Once again I digress.

    I love Freedom's worry for Sev and Hagrid's caring also.

    It seems a little bit strange to me that there does not appear to be more worry about the missing Gryffindor. Sev has not taken an active part in any search since the first night. And he just says that HArry is off sulking somewhere and everyone believes him. I wonder, just as a matter of protocol whether the Dursleys have been notified that their nephew is missing. After all, everyone seems to think Harry leads a normal, happy existence with them. Severus certainly does.

    Onwards.

    Lesley~

    Author's Response:

    Yes, Minerva and the rest of them do admire Albus and so does Hagrid.  Poppy has a hard time reconciling the fact that Severus is continually hurt in Albus's service, and she fears that however wellmeaning, the Headmaster is using Severus for his own ends, using the guilt he feels over Lily's death to keep him playing spy.  She knows, rationally, that Severus has agreed but it still pains her to see him hurt so badly.  She would never hurt Albus, Healer's oath and her own conscience would prevent her.

    Dumbledore's early life as the son of wealthy purebloods and as a popular and brilliant child at school is known to the public in my universe and Severus believes that such an upbringing doesn't give Dumbledore the necessary empathy to understand one like himself, who had an awful childhood and once contemplated ending his own life.  DD never saw the signs Severus was giving off, granted they weren't many, but DD didn;t see them, and in that way he failed Severus, because Sev believes he SHOULD have seen them. 

    A lot of the search for Harry with the other teachers takes place behind the scenes.  After Snape's initial search, where he tells Albus that Harry is hiding, he also went out a few other times, but again finds nothing.  They do know, because of Severus's torture, that the DE don;t have Harry, and since none of their locator spells have turned up anything, they have to assume that Harry is somewhere on the grounds, since his broom is still in his dorm.  Dumbledore will announce that they need to keep searching and are concerned over Harry;s disappearance at a staff dinner coming up.  Also, DD wouldn't want it to be known that he has "lost" Harry Potter and so hasn't informed the Dursleys.  Not that they would care.  At the end of the first book, when Harry is recovering in the Hospital Wing, only DD comes to visit him besides his friends, and maybe DD never told the Dursleys about that time either.  Of course he should notify them, it would be SOP in any regular school, but then when has Hogwarts ever been normal?

Title: Birds of A Feather 06 May 2009 9:23 am
Reviewer: wrappedinharry (Signed) [Report This]
    If Freedom could vaguely remember a one-eyed wizard TALKING about the Cruciatus Curse, you would think he would remember actually EXPERIENCING the curse himself. But with amnesia, I am sure memories are not necessarily equal to the intensity of ones previous experiences. Though I think that would be the case. Though you do not depict DD as beingevil in this story...far from it in fact, he does come across as a doddering old fool without any empathy or sympathy at all. Once again I am talking about an earlier chapter when you said that the Marauders got away scot free when they (and here, I must say I think Sirius was acting alone) almost got Severus killed. I do not think this would have been the case. I think Sirius would have been punished quite severely for the prank (that's an awfully insignificant word considering the intent behind the action)as far as DD could do without actually expelling him. If he had expelled him, questions would have been raised by other parents (as the Blacks were a very prestigious wizarding family) and Lupin's lycanthropy would have come to light and his removal from the school demanded. You said (I think) that Severus was threatened with expulsion if he ever spoke of the incident. I feel this is very extreme and I do not think DD would have been that cold-hearted. Severus would have been content with nothing less than the expulsion of all four Marauders because he is convinced that they were all in on the plot.

    These are just my ruminations on the subject. Please do not take them as criticisms. Your story is wonderful and you of course can do with it as you will. We all do make up our own plot lines after all.

    Voldemort was suitably evil and cruel and I loved the touch of him having to imbibe Severus's despair, just like a dementor.

    I love how close Freedom is getting to Sev and vice versa. I also love how you have given Severus healing skills. MY own story (A Shocking Discovery) actually has Severus being a fully trained healer, but this is kept mostly secret from the wider wizarding world.

    Cannot wait for Harry (Freedom) to get his memory back fully and for Severus to realise who his Familiar is.

    Hope you don't mind the long, long rambling reviews.

    Lesley~

    Author's Response:

    That's the funny thing about the mind, with amnesia or without it, sometimes the mind tends to block out horrible  things that happen to you. 

    I am sort of following canon in my portrayal of Dumbledore--he is a manipulator, but with good intentions, and he also has several blind spots concerning the Marauders.  He never really curbed their pranks, at least to my understanding, perhaps because he thought they were harmless, but also because he was a prankster himself in his youth.  Sirius was the mastermind behind that so-called prank, but I think James probably went along with it, as a kind of let's scare Snape witless thing, until he realized it would mean Snape's death and then he acted to save him.  Funny how Peter was never mentioned, maybe he was hiding somewhere nearby in rat shape? In any case, I don;t think those two were punished beyond a few detentions and a lecture, since Severus never felt vindicated. In canon, he says "your father and his friends played a highly amusing joke on me and nearly got me killed" if he's still angry and bitter about it all those years later, that suggests to me that they were never punished for it.  Of course, Dumbledore couldn't expel them, but whatever he did do to them didn't leave much of an impression, because Sirius doesn;t seem to feel any kind of regret or remorse over almost killing Snape. He kind of seems to think that Snape deserved it, at least that is my interpretation of events.  DD threatens to expel Severus because it is the only way he can assure himself that Sev keeps his mouth shut, without binding him magically.  It was  a bluff, he never would have followed through, but Severus didn't know that.  ironically, in attempting to save Remus, Albus causes the potential suicide Severus to think that no one cares and leads him inadvertantly to nearly take his own life.  Of course DD never knows that, otherwise he would feel terrible and try to make amends.  But Severus never told him, and only Hagrid knows the truth.

    It just makes sense for me to make Severus a healer and a Potions Master. In my other series, Never Again, Severus is a Master Healer, a doctor and Potions Master.  It's a very AU universe where Voldemort is killed suring the first war by James, Sirius, and Remus, though james dies trying to kill him.  Severus is also friends with Remus, Sirius, and James, they were never enemies.  Lily eventually marries Sev and he adopts Harry.  This series focus mainly on family relationships, raising a mischievius magical toddler, and Snape's reconciliation with his abusive former alcoholic father Tobias.

    Eventually Freedom will regain his memories. 

    No, i don't mind long reviews.  I just write long replys. LOL!

Title: Hawk Speak 06 May 2009 3:13 am
Reviewer: wrappedinharry (Signed) [Report This]
    Thank you for all of your review replies. I love hearing back from the author after I review...not everyone does it. In response to your response to my last review, I just want to say that I do realise that not all of the Slytherins can be bad and that there are DEs from other houses...there would have to be. I was very disappointed in Deathly Hallows when the whole of the Slytherin house got up to leave when McGonagall told them to do so before the battle. My thoughts about that are that if any of them did have sympathy for HArry and are secretly against Voldemort, then they are afraid of repercussions and prefer to keep their heads down.

    Anyway, to this chapter. I liked that Severus could talk to his bird, but I found it a little disconcerting that Harry hawks use of language is so human. But I suppose that is because he is an animagus. He seems to have the instincts of a hawk, but even with his memory loss, he seems to have a human's perceptions.

    I just never thought that animals of any species other than humans and perhaps dolphins could communicate vocally with each other. It is more body language. So HArry hawks language skills are a little disconcerting.

    Lesley

    Author's Response:

    I always try and reply to all my reviewers, i figure it's only polite since they took the time to leave a review and I also like discussing topics with reviewers since I don't do chat rooms. 

    That could be why the Slytherins didn't stand up and declare themselves, but I was waiting for some of them to just say "Down with Voldy" and go and stand up for themselves.  I was disappointed when that didn't happen. 

    Part of the reason Harry sounds so human is because he's an Animagus, but also it's how the potion "translates" the hawk language for Severus to comprehend.  For instance, i would assume a bird has more vocal cues and such than a dog or a cat, who communicate more with body language, but a bird also uses posture for defense and to indicate fear and aggression and affection, and all of that is translated into human speech by magic.  But even in hawk form, Harry's personality comes out, which would fit with how an Animagus keeps his own mind while in animal form, along with the animal instincts. Plus, it's fun to have Severus and Harry banter with each other, especially since Severus doesn't know who he's really talking to.  It increases the bond between them, which will be important later on.

Title: No Excuse 06 May 2009 2:23 am
Reviewer: Pandora (Signed) [Report This]
    Aw, I really hope that Sirius comes round. Maybe he just needs to calm down a bit and he'll finally see the light.

    I also hope that Sirius and Snape can put aside their animosity and fight against Voldie.

    Author's Response:

    Yes, he does need to calm down and have a long talk with Remus. 

    They will try, for Harry's sake if for nothing else.

    Hope you like the next part.

Title: No Excuse 05 May 2009 10:16 pm
Reviewer: Judy (Signed) [Report This]
    Great little conversation between Harry, Crabbe, and Jace. Hope they stay friends and can't wait to see what they do to Malfoy. Make it a good prank!

    The argument between Harry and Sirius was very well done, I could feel it all, and am glad Harry told Sirius the way he really feels. You go, boy!

    Can't wait for the Order meeting. Thanks for writing!

    Author's Response: Okay, I will. Thanks so much!
Title: No Excuse 05 May 2009 10:09 pm
Reviewer: little-sun (Signed) [Report This]
    What a fight. I am surprised that Severus didn't tell Harry off for losing his control (I guess a still-hurting part in him was glad to see Freedom defending him so passionatelly). I am looking forward to reading about the Order meeting - update soon, please. Mila

    Author's Response:

    Yes, that's so.  And Severus knows how hard it was for Harry to keep his temper with Sirius being his stubborn git self.

     

    I just updated the next part.  Thanks!

Title: No Excuse 05 May 2009 8:47 pm
Reviewer: DrSnape (Signed) [Report This]
    Wow1 Loved this chapter, Sirius really needed to hear what Harry said and I hope Remus can get him to see sense before he says something unforgivable to Severus or Harry.

    Author's Response: That's great, Remus is probably the only one who can make Sirius listen to reason. 
Title: No Excuse 05 May 2009 6:54 pm
Reviewer: Aeryun (Signed) [Report This]
    OOOOHHHH! Thank you! Someone finally let Sirius have it! :D It's Remus' turn next. Can't wait for more! :D

    Author's Response: Yes, I had fun writing this chapter.  I always felt he got away with a bit too much in the original series.  Nobody ever really called him on the awful way he behaved in canon.  It kind of got shrugged off.  That was not right, which is why that doesn't happen in my fic.  More has been posted!

Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5