I really disapprove of a certain tone deaf old coot.
| Title: Chapter 26
| 01 Dec 2010 7:09 am
|
| Reviewer: Helese (Anonymous)
| [Report This]
|
Who was watching!?!?!
Dumbledore is such a prat! I like your take on how D would regard Harry were he sorted Slytherin.
| Title: Chapter 26
| 16 Nov 2007 5:00 am
|
| Reviewer: Tabitha (Anonymous)
| [Report This]
|
Hi. I am really enjoying your story. I just found it and it is absolutely wonderul. Your Snape and Harry and both wonderfully written and in character. I am also really having fun getting to know the other Slyterins. Can't wait for more.
Oh holy sh*t!! Can I smack Dumbledore really hard?! I can't believe that he and that old crab McGonagall are actually suggesting that Harry is cheating just because he's Sytherin!! I hate how the Slytherins' are treated in canon, and you've managed to reflect it nicely here - I'm so glad that Harry has Severus in his corner now, as I know Severus will do whatever it takes to keep Harry safe, and help him succeed!! Terrific chapter, and as always I look forward to more!!
Scarlett
Great chapter! I loved the discussion between Harry and Severus. It took a lot of courage for Harry to ask if his father's past behavior influenced Severus' treatment of him (even if he did go about it in a roundabout way), and I was glad that Severus restrained himself and responded appropriately.
I'm a bit with Dumbledore at the moment--he really is prejudiced against the Slytherins, and that's not good. I hope he'll come around at some point. But it's great to see Severus assuming the reponsibility of protecting Harry, too.
Looking forward to more!
| Title: Chapter 26
| 15 Nov 2007 2:50 am
|
| Reviewer: MorwenIsilwen (Anonymous)
| [Report This]
|
Yikes. Dumbledore's a bit scary. I love the way that you're unfolding this story!
I don't have much new to say about your stories, but I continue to enjoy them as much as when I first started reading them, and I figured a review can't go wrong (so long as it isn't a flame). I think the Dumbledore you portray is slightly different from the book, but I think he's accurate with regards to Harry being placed in Severus' control. Keep up the great work!!
I really liked the way you handled the conversation between Harry and Snape regarding James and Snape's reasons for his earlier treatment of Harry. This is one of the things you do very, very well, stretching out this kind of tense and emotional scene, without going overboard into sentimentalism, but keeping a lot of depth as well as suspense as the reader waits to see just how the characters will react toward one another.
Excellent chapter as always! I'm glad Harry has finally been able to catch up on his studies. Keep up the outstanding writing!
| Title: Chapter 26
| 14 Nov 2007 8:22 am
|
| Reviewer: Eva (Signed)
| [Report This]
|
Wow, wow, wow!!! Okay, I'll stop saying that. But really, I loved the chapter and I am hoping that there is another update soon. That was one superb chapter, especially the conversation between Harry and Snape. They seem so in character, it's something I would love to have in my story.
|