Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For Lily's Charm
Title: Chapter 10: Interfering Old Coot 06 Dec 2007 1:52 pm
Reviewer: Phoenix1 (Signed) [Report This]
    where did snape go?

    Author's Response: You'll just have to wait and see....   :oP
Title: Chapter 10: Interfering Old Coot 06 Dec 2007 1:48 pm
Reviewer: Rimma (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Oh! Oh, Harry, poor Harry. I love this story so much! I’m on the edge of my seat for more. You’ve hooked me so completely to their lives and their pains. They’re a mess but they have such potential to be incredibly happy and its torturous to read the struggle, but brilliant! and I can’t wait to read more. *LOVES*

    Author's Response: Thank you!  Thanks so much for the review.  I'm glad you like the story so much and I love that you are feeling the pain for these people.  It is been really painful to write some of these chapters.  More is coming soon.  Lots more angst and drama for you too!  :o)
Title: Chapter 10: Interfering Old Coot 06 Dec 2007 9:57 am
Reviewer: cathyrf (Signed) [Report This]
    Wow.....

    Oh wow...

    Kind of picking myself off the floor with this installment. Yikes!

    I'm glad the new revelations came out immediately (and what and why does Dumbledore know what he knows....clearly so much more than meets the eye). Hmmm....

    The Snape fury at the end.....LOVED IT! I wouldn't want to be Mummy right now...that confrontation will not be pretty.

    And how will Snape react to Harry when he returns?

    So many questions! You have all the answers! As I said before, your story has grabbed me hook, line and sinker and I'm glad you update frequently. I haunted the computer this evening when you mentioned you'd be updating again. I only do that when a story "speaks" to me in the way yours has. Bravo!

    Author's Response:

    Thank you so much.  I'm thrilled by how much you are enjoying the story.  I think yeah, something had to give and Harry just wasn't going to wait around anymore...that is a boy of action! 

    Dumbledore is always up to something, isn't he?  :)

    Glad you liked Snape at the end there.  Those were really fun paragraphs to craft.  I just adore a furious Snape, don't you?  Almost as much as a warm and fuzzy one.  LOL

    The next chapter will be up in a couple days, I hope.  I hope you keep enjoying and that my story keeps "speaking" to you.  Thanks again for your awesome review.   

Title: Chapter 10: Interfering Old Coot 06 Dec 2007 9:24 am
Reviewer: JMGodfreyIII (Anonymous) [Report This]
    virtual chocolate frogs for being so good about updating this awesome story ^_^

    Author's Response: Yummy...chocolate frogs.  :o) 
Title: Chapter 9: Truth 05 Dec 2007 11:40 pm
Reviewer: cathyrf (Signed) [Report This]
    Wow - this is exciting! I just read chapters 1-9 straight through and I'm on pins and needles! You've definitely got another reader hooked here.

    Love how you're writing all the characters. Can't wait until the next chapter.

    Author's Response: YAY!  Thanks so much for reviewing.  It's great to have another excited reader.  The next chapter will even be up later tonight as I just have a couple of tweaks to do to it once the kids get to bed!  Thanks for the compliment about the characterizations!  They are so much fun to write.  Hope you keep enjoying!
Title: Chapter 9: Truth 05 Dec 2007 7:46 pm
Reviewer: curlybean (Signed) [Report This]
    Oh my goodness. It all makes sense now, doesn't it? At least I think it does. I feel so sorry for both Lily and Severus, and now for Harry, too. I do wonder, though, if Dumbledore is as clueless about this as he acts. I'm thinking that he knows everything there is to know and for whatever reason he's keeping it from Snape and Harry. I don't think they will be too happy if they find out that he's hiding something so important from them.

    Thanks for the update. Can't wait for the next....

    Author's Response:

    Yeah, at least it makes sense to Harry.  And yeah, this has been really hard to write as it is so filled with so many emotions for all of them.  What a happy family they could have been....

    Well, there is lots of good old Dumbledore in the next chapter so I guess we'll see what the old coot is up to...maybe.  :o)

    The update is coming soon.  Thanks for the review!

Title: Chapter 9: Truth 05 Dec 2007 5:59 pm
Reviewer: Sevvus_Harry (Signed) [Report This]
    Wow! So Harry really is Sev's son... Poor Sev, he didn't think Lily would actually betrayed him, did he? Stupid Eileen Prince...

    Author's Response: Yeah, Eileen really is a problem, isn't she?  And, hey you're almost writing lines from my next chapter there with your review.  :o)  Thanks for reviewing!
Title: Chapter 9: Truth 05 Dec 2007 5:15 pm
Reviewer: Syret (Signed) [Report This]
    LOVE IT!!!LOVE IT!!!LOVE IT!!!

    Author's Response: THANK YOU!!!THANK YOU!!!THANK YOU!!!  :)
Title: Chapter 9: Truth 05 Dec 2007 4:09 pm
Reviewer: Rimma (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Oh I feel so bad for Severus. It hurts to read. Poor guy. It’s going to be heartbreaking to read how he reacts when he finds out but I’m still really looking forward to it.

    I'm enjoying this story so much! It’s really evolving, I’ve got all caught up in it. Thank you for sharing it and I’m really looking forward to reading the next chapter :)

    Author's Response:

    Thanks so much for reviewing.  I know what you mean; it was really painful to write.  I actually teared up when I wrote the end of chapter 8.  Some much pain for Severus. 

     I'm glad you are liking it so much.  The next chapter should be up soon!  

Title: Chapter 9: Truth 05 Dec 2007 4:44 am
Reviewer: Elfwyn (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Very interesting twist, however, like many stories I feel you have Harry forgiving way too easily. He is a teenager with a temper and should hold a grudge equal in abilities to his father's, especially after Albus said he'd told Harry everything about him after Sirius died. (Case in point is his canon attitude to Malfoy.) Let's not forget that learning Occulmency against his wishes would be mind rape and he need to stand up to his teachers, after all none of them are his guardians or parents. Remus has no say in his life. Harry needs to keep his backbone he is after all almost an adult in their world.

    Author's Response:

    Thank you for the review.  I had to reread chapter nine to figure out what you were referring to, so I hope I understood correctly. I assume you were talking about Harry not getting angry with Remus after Remus apologized for not telling Harry about Snape and Lily. I think we have to remember that Harry had just gone through a terrible emotional ordeal and he was in no shape to argue further.  And the fact is, Remus does have a good point.  What was he supposed to say about Lily and Snape, especially when it was not his story to tell?  Remus didn't know that Snape and Lily were married.  He did know that James and Lily had married for something like protection for Lily and yes, he knows that Lily loves Snape, but I think too that Remus, given that he seems the kind of man who just wants everything to work out (and the fact that supposedly Lily and James had been close enough to produce a baby), he believed that Lily loved James as well.  And the bottom line is that Remus thought James was Harry's father, not Snape.  If he had known, and he still didn't tell Harr, then yes his actions would have been indefensible, but as it is, I don't believe they are.  Remember too that once Harry thought Remus had known more than he actually did, Harry was quite a bit more angry.  Same goes for Dumbledore, if he fact does not know Lily lied to Snape. 

     As to Harry having no backbone, I actually think Harry did quite well for himself as he did flatly refuse to resume Occlumency with Snape.  He even went so far as the turn his back on both Remus and Dumbledore and walk out.  He was not inclined to defy McGonagall the next night but he went to Dumbledore's office fully intending to refuse again.  And, in all actuality, Dumbledore could not have insisted as you are right...it would be completely wrong of all of them.  And, you are right, Remus has no say in Harry's life but if you you were referring to Remus' telling Harry not to defy the Headmaster, I think that is simply Professor Lupin telling Harry not to be impertinent, much as McGonagall did later. And, yes Harry is nearing adulthood but he is not an adult and I think it is perfectly acceptable for the adults in his life to expect respect from him, even when Harry is too stubborn and angry to give it.  

    I do appreciate your sentiments and thank you for giving me something to think about.  Hopefully, I explained myself well enough.  Hope you keep enjoying the story! 


Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5