Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Title: The Strangest Birthday Ever 30 Aug 2008 2:48 am
Reviewer: Pandora (Signed) [Report This]
    Wow, I love your story! Harry is SO Slytherin! The dymanics are great, and so funny!

    Nice long chapter too! I'm looking forward to see where you are going with this story.

    Author's Response: thank you for your review, I seem to like making Harry show his Slytherin side more
Title: The Strangest Birthday Ever 29 Aug 2008 11:00 pm
Reviewer: Jan_AQ (Signed) [Report This]
    I really like sick or injured Harry stories, and when he's rebellious it makes a better story. :) This story has a lot of potential but the mistakes make it difficult to read, and I think that jars readers from the story so that they can;t enjoy it as much. Please watch for typos and capitalization. "I" should always be capitalized. If a person wears clothes, it is on their body, but a ware is a type of goods. "Muggle" should always be capitalized.

    Severus woke the next morning thinking about what he was going to to for the little trouble maker's birthday today. ' the boy needs a companion' he thought.' and maybe a new wardrobe, because all he wares is clothes that hang off him unless he wares his school uniform' he added in his head Severus got out of bed gather some clothes and headed into his bathroom to take a shower.

    Thoughts using ' is fine, but they must use the same punctuation as quotation marks, and all the same grammar. You are missing periods, and you are missing words. Things like "i" and "snape" are not capitalized. This really should not be. If you are having problems catching these things when you edit your story, then you need to find a beta reader to help correct your work for you. You can find one by posting a message on the Potions and Snitches yahoo group, and there are websites dedicated to beta services that I'm sure you can find if you search for them. Making the chapters shorter may help too, because then you wouldn't have as much to go through.

    Your story has a lot of great potential, and could be very enjoyable so please keep working on it, and don't give up! :) Your story could be very good.
Title: The Strangest Birthday Ever 29 Aug 2008 10:59 pm
Reviewer: graynavarre (Signed) [Report This]
    I got a bit confused with Melissa. I take it that she is Snape full sister, that their father hide in the attic (due to some inheritance thing) and she somehow got out several years ago.

    The chapter was good but almost too long. I like long chapters but you put too much in one reading. It probably would have worked better as two chapters.

    Other than some spelling errors and the lenght, I am enjoying it. Harry needs to get over his snit and start trying to behave and get well

    Looking forward to more.

    Author's Response: sorry i confused you, yes Melissa is Severus full sister their father Tobias made her live in the attic because he did not want to acknowledge that he had a daughter, and refuse to let Eileen tell Severus that he had a sister , Melissa left Spinner's End at age 17 when Tobias had left for the day.
Title: The Meddling Potions Master 29 Aug 2008 10:46 pm
Reviewer: Jan_AQ (Signed) [Report This]
    I really, really like the plot, and how Snape caught Harry from off his broom where he fell. Lovely. :) I like the pace and direction very much! The anger and emotions in the story are very good. But there are a lot of errors in the writing that makes this story very difficult to read. Mostly they are things like spelling errors, punctuation, and tenses. Maybe a couple of run on sentences. For example:

    Severus Snape looked down at the boy " Yes Potter , you are lucky I got here at the right time or you would have killed yourself from that fall, what were you running from Potter?" Snape asked the boy before he passes out again.

    Quotation marks should always be touching the opening letter of dialogue, and commas should always touch the word before them (like periods) so it should be like this: Severus Snape looked down at the boy, "Yes Potter, you are lucky..." There always has to be some sort of punctuation before the opening quotation of dialogue (and a space afterwards, not before) unless it starts a new paragraph. New paragraphs should be started whenever a new person speaks. Periods should end every thought, commas should only be used to link partial thoughts, otherwise it creates a run on sentence. So it should be like this: "...you are lucky I got here at the right time or you would have killed yourself from that fall. What were you running from, Potter?"

    Watch your tenses: Snape asked the boy before he passes out again.

    this is a tricky sentence, I know, but you have a past tense, and a present tense, and those should not be mixed in the narrative.

    Good story idea, and keep working on it! :)
Title: The Meddling Potions Master 05 Aug 2008 1:51 am
Reviewer: SnapesYukuai (Anonymous) [Report This]
    CUTE!! CUTE!! CUTE!! Did I say I love it? No? Okay, I'll do it now: I love your story!!! I could read "Sev takes cre of an injured (or healthy) Harry" all day (and night). Please, do me the favour an update quickly.
Title: The Meddling Potions Master 03 Aug 2008 12:16 am
Reviewer: A-zla (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Mh, a good story! I hope Harry is going to give up trying to escape, I don't really understand why he tries so hard. Maybe Snape will make him tell...
    I hope you're going to put this on fanfaiction.net, I never manage to get the alerts working here.
Title: The Meddling Potions Master 01 Aug 2008 6:04 pm
Reviewer: graynavarre (Signed) [Report This]
    It was fun to watch Severus bounce back and forth from Harry to Draco. It was like watching a tennis game.

    Author's Response: I am glad you liked the first chapter, I will posting the second chapter soon after i fix it

Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5