|
Reviews For Harry's New Home
You are an amazing author. There is no doubt about it. As a reader, I personally found this chapter, especially the 'talk' that Snape had with Harry HIGHLY disturbing. I had to fight myself to read through it. THIS Snape in unfit to be anybody's guardian. Being abused himself, he doesn't recognize the signed of an abuse victim and definitely doesn't have the ability to deal with one. He tried to tell Harry that he can be good at his studies by saying "doesn't your TINY BRAIN comprehend..." He went on to threatening him in order for him to refrain from misbehaving and putting himself in danger, rather than explaining to him. Harry doesn't remember his parents, yet the first thing Snape tells Harry about James is that he was a bully. Just because he can't get over his schoolboy grudge and insecurities, he dragged Harry into it. Harry being bullied himself is obviously going to despise his father for being one. Then he went on to being overly satisfied for his nemesis's son to apologize to him on belhalf on his father. He thinks he's gotten his revenge by doing so? After ruining a father's (who dies protecting him) image in his son's eyes he says not to "think too harshly of your father." I believe children should NEVER be dragged into their parents' affairs or be told of their negative actions when they are so loving and caring towards their children. I honestly hope he changes quickly and I can keep enjoying your writing.
“Doing what right?” "Hugging. I only did it once before, when Mrs Weasley said goodbye to me and Ron at the station." /cryes buckets/ Seriously, that's so pathedic and sad and adorable all wrapped together. And now I want to give him a hug - and coming from me, that's saying quite a bit.
I'm quite impressed with everything from your writing style to characterization to the way you're maneuvering this plot into place. There have been more than a couple times in these few chapters that I've laughed out loud. I'm quite excited to read more (and quite pleased there's so much more to read)!
seriously, it is *really* good. I thought the dialogue in this chapter was phenomenal. you did a great job writing out Harry's confusion and Snape's thought process trying to explain every single thing! I can't wait to read more!
Author's Response: Thank you very much! I try to leaven the serious topics with humor - always great to hear when it works! :)
Author's Response: LOL! Thank you for being kind enough to review and let me know that you enjoyed it! :)
Author's Response: Thank you - update coming up!
Author's Response: LOL! Well, in that case I guess I'll let you off for not being specific. :) Next chapter coming up!
Author's Response: Thank you!! It's great to hear that you're enjoying the story - the letters have been surprisingly popular! I'll have to keep including them. :)
Author's Response: Thank you! Of course, in real life abuse is never as quickly forgotten or recovered from as it is in fiction, but hopefully this story will be able to carry it off... :) |
Powered by eFiction 3.5 |