Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For Broken Wings
Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 8:32 pm
Reviewer: Quynce (Signed) [Report This]
    It would be hard to imagine a fate too horrible for Umbridge-- and her avian punishment fits into the story nicely. It was nice to see Sev and Minvera working together intelligently to solve a problem for Harry. Cannon seems to insist that adults are untrustworthy, unavailable, and somewhat oblivious to the children's needs. Fanfiction often takes a hard line against that, insisting that some adults are responsible and willing to protect children. Since Harry seems to be somewhat abused (it's less severe in cannon than fannon), I think a lot of readers object to the cannon message that kids need to struggle on their own because no adult will protect them. It's a dangerous message to give abused kids. That's one of the reasons this type of fic seems so moving-- because Harry shouldn't have to fix everything and suffer silently.
    I like the complication with Ron and I can't wait to see Sev and Harry try to relate as two people (rather than just wizard and familiar).

    Author's Response: Yes, I agree.  Umbridge was soo awful . . . as bad as Moldy Voldy in her way.  I agree with the canon message, since it seems that JKR wanted to have a self-suffiecine tboy hero who can solve things that most adults would have trouble dealing with.  It's sad, really, since every child should have one adult he can count on.  That's why I made it so that Severus is there for Harry and to a lesser extent so are McGonagall and Hagrid.  Because you're right, no child should be expected to save the world and suffer in silence.  I believe that one of the main components of a hero is that you can rely on others to help you and cooperation is more important to solve problems that bravery and those solo Charge of the Valkyries.  But that's me.  Thank you for reading!
Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 7:11 pm
Reviewer: FrostedMidnight (Signed) [Report This]
    *Falls over, gigling madly* hee...you actually let the birds eat her!! How sadisticly wonderfull! I abosolutely loooved this chapter! Not only did we get rid of Umbridge, but now Harry and Sev get to spend more time together!.... Ding dong the witch is dead, we sicced a bird upon her head, ding dong the wicked witch is dead *Hums joyfully under breath*

    Author's Response: Wow that's a cool rhyme! Glad you enjoyed her death so much, I certainly enjoyed giving her what she deserved for once.
Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 6:10 pm
Reviewer: wellyuthink (Signed) [Report This]
    Wow. That Stymphalian Bird was scray! I'm definitely glad I'm not Umbridge - she certainly got what was coming to her. I love Minerva's brilliant idea!

    Author's Response:

    It was, and the picture I saw on the web was even scarier!

    Thanks and hope you like the next bit.

Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 6:00 pm
Reviewer: Lady Julie Snape (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Eight chapters to go, high-ho, high-ho, high-ho, high-ho, high-ho.

    So, what type of bird is Severus?

    You can no longer deny it! You haven't responded to any of my reviews so I /know/ he's an animagus! C'mon, why do you have to keep me in suspense???

    Update soon, darling.

    Author's Response:

    Well, eight or nine, you never know how it'll work out. 

    What makes you think he's a bird???

    Well, sweetie, if I told you . . .it'd ruin the surprise!!

    And we wouldn;t want that, now would we?

    The next one is up now, so enjoy!

Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 5:59 pm
Reviewer: Morgansnape87 (Signed) [Report This]
    Yay.! good chapter way to get rid of The evil witch.

    Author's Response: Thanks! Claps now that the b**** is dead!
Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 5:13 pm
Reviewer: CeeCeeMee (Signed) [Report This]
    Wonderful!! I was afraid that even if she was arrested she (or with Fudge's help) would get away with what she had done. And how perfect that her biggest fear came true.

    Good job with Ron's attitude and reactions. He always reacts first and then thinks later. Sometimes much, much later.

    Snape's apprentice, eh? Well done. He'll get some remedial help he should have gotten in first year, someone to look over his homework assignments, a reason for being with Snape as much as he not-so-secretly wants, and more importantly has an adult he can talk to and rely on. Well done, indeed.

    Author's Response:

    That's quite true, since Fudge would have done something to keep her out of Azkaban.  Bad for his image . . .you know.  And you know what they say . . .sometimes karma takes a hand.

    Ron does indeed react first and think about it later.

    Yes, he will, and Severus will be sure to give him the stability and guidance as well as compassion the boy needs.  Thanks!

Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 4:55 pm
Reviewer: Pandora (Signed) [Report This]
    Was it Freedom himself that killed Umbridge? Yikes, what a way to die. I'm glad that she's dead though.

    So as Snape's apprentice, does Harry have to live with him? Will that give Snape custody over Harry, and what happens if he reports Harry's relatives?

    I know, I know, so many questions! LOL! Update soon please I can't wait to see what happens next. Will you show a confrontation with the muggles and Snape?

    Author's Response:

    No, the Stymphalaina Bird was not summoned by Freedom, he didn;t even know it existed.  It was just bad timing . . .or luck . . .or karma coming back onto her. 

    Well, he could . . .but not right away.  You'll see what the apprenticeship entails next chapter, and I would imagine Severus could report them for negligence and other abuse if he wanted to.

    Yes, I could do that too, I don;t know what I'll be doing in regards to them yet, though.

Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 4:23 pm
Reviewer: Wyrsa (Signed) [Report This]
    Brilliant!
    Pity Ron is not adult yet to see sense, hope he will be cured of it.
    The part in Umbridge's office was great! Ancient justice came upon her head.

    Author's Response:

    Yes, Ron needs a reality check and a stern talking to from someone!

    Glad you enjoyed Dolores's fate.  Ancient justice came, all right, and it saw and it conquered.

Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 3:10 pm
Reviewer: La Mariane (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Umbridge out of Hogwarts at last!
    I really liked the quarrel between Harry and Ron, I think you managed to paint a really IC Ron.
    And I liked McGonagall, and her solution for Harry and Severus :-)

    Author's Response:

    Isn;t it great~ let's have a party!!

    Oh good, because sometimes Ron is hard for me to write.

    Minerva can be very clever at times, especially when it comes to helping out Harry.

Title: The Toad At Bay 25 Apr 2009 2:06 pm
Reviewer: fanficaholic (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Awesome!! Glad Umbitch got hers!! Looking forward to Harry as Severus' apprentice!

    Author's Response: Thanks! I'm glad too! Now you can see how harry and Sev are getting along.

Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5