Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For Antonomasia
Title: Chapter 13 24 Feb 2010 7:26 am
Reviewer: GraveDigger_Resurrection (Signed) [Report This]
    Okay, on a scale of One to Epic, this story is like at least a twelve. I just love it. It's so raw and hurt-y in all the right ways. My favorite part is actually the flashback bits-- the stuff Harry is hearing that people have said to him, because it's such a chilling, cutting way to show where is mind is. I love that you're doing it through "showing" instead of *just* "telling". Also, good on Snape for being shut of the spying thing. I always feel better when he gets out, no matter how almost-deadly it is. And a billion points to Dobby for being awesome.

    Or, you know, a billion points to *you* for being awesome and writing this. Eagerly awaiting an update! :)

    Author's Response:

    Oh *blushes... and grins madly* thank you!!! That’s such a wonderful thing to hear!!! And that you like my flashbacks is one of the biggest compliments ever! Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU! And I totally agree, Snape was so completely in the wrong profession and needed a career change so I gave him one ^^ and I’d give Dobby points but I don’t know if that would count as clothes...? (a billion points to you instead? ^^) (oooh, if they go to me maybe I can just say Ravenclaw wins my tally... hmm... possibly cheating though >.< ... ^^) Thanks!!!

Title: Chapter 13 18 Feb 2010 7:03 am
Reviewer: Stephanie (Anonymous) [Report This]
    I absolutely LOVED this entire fic so far! I always thought that if Umbridge thought she would be able to get away with more, she would have gone for it. I love how you incorporated Harry's home life into, basically dictating how he reacts towards Umbridge and why he doesnt go to anyone with this. I cannot wait for you to update with the next chapter!

    Author's Response:

    Oh thank you! I’m so glad you’re liking it and that you really get the psychology behind Harry in this (or what I’m going for with it anyway ^^) – and Umbridge was nothing if not inventive, I always thought she wasn’t given enough room to move as a character so I thought I’d be nice and give her a chance... how wrong I was *shakes head woefully* ^^ - hope you like the update... soon ^^ and Thanks!!!

Title: Chapter 13 11 Feb 2010 3:45 pm
Reviewer: crazychick84 (Signed) [Report This]
    Ooh! I found this a couple of days ago but onlu just finished because pesky work got in my way! (bad bad work!) im glad that im all caught up now cause I can get all excited about updates lol, I love the idea and cant wait to see exactly what that potion was that Umbridge gave Harry (the evil evil hag!) I do hope there will be plenty of 'AWWWW' worthy moments between Harry and Snape, I love those sooo much and am a sucker for them hehe, cant wait to read more :D (I am Slytherin through and through btw!)

    Author's Response:

    Thank you! Work is bad but lovely reviews are wonderful (and a much better use of time ^-^)  Awwww moments are on their way (and sorry for getting you all caught up and following up with no updates, how horrible of me... there’s one on the way if it helps at all?)

    Oh, and all you points are of course going towards a Slytherinny victory ^-^ Thanks!

Title: Chapter 13 09 Feb 2010 4:33 am
Reviewer: Wyrsa (Anonymous) [Report This]
    "Harry shivered even as he pushed the door open."
    Right, I shivered too.))
    My, I can't choose my favourite line, even multiple lines... For me the most favourite part of this chapter is the supreme quality of writing, the clear, gentle and intense emotion filling every inch of text.
    The scene with Lily, the exalted feeling of freedom in Snape - that was huge sigh of relief when he escaped, great he IS free now... almost - and the abrupt inverting of this feeling in deepest anxiety. Your Snape may not be strictly canonical, but I LOVE the way you wright him. It's facinating. By the by you made me dead curious, how did OldVold get to be so sure of Snape's betrayal?
    Well, I'm still a bit overwhelmed with emotions.))) You've done very, very well, the best muffins ever baked on this Earth all for you, you've made me the happiest reader today! Thank you!

    Author's Response:

    Oh, thank you! *covers you in Sev’s warm cloak* sorry about the shivers ^^

    Hehe, no, you couldn’t say my Sev was canonical so much anymore but I like to think that given these circumstances the Snape of the books would be altered just the slightest bit (and perhaps not as much as he is in this but then I did promise comfort and cuddling didn’t I... ^^) – thank you so, SO much; I can’t say how reassuring it is to know that you like where this appears to be going – when writing for enjoyment it’s fantastic to know that its enjoyed, you know? ^^

    And in my head Voldy knew about Snape because he was tipped off by someone sneaky and evil and malicious (and I like to think petty because, for some reason in my head it’s wormtail... though it might not always be so, but I do think it would suit the little sh- sneak (^-^) to have been the one to get Snape in trouble, even if only to rise in the ranks himself) – I might explore it more later but feel free to use your imagination too ^-^

    Oh!  Sorry to overwhelm you, even if its a good overwhelmyness *shares best muffins ever with you*  (muffins are, of course, much better when shared with a friend ^^) – thank you heaps and heaps and heaps, hope the next update is as good as the muffins ^^

Title: Chapter 13 07 Feb 2010 8:23 pm
Reviewer: Chandramas (Signed) [Report This]
    Emm Just a quick post, you know, to nag you about another chapter...

    Author's Response:

    Haha, ahh, you’ve discovered my ‘5 points for every review’ policy somehow haven’t you?  Or do you... kinda... maybe... possibly... want an update?  Hmm, I’ll take a few months to ponder it... *holds up hands in surrender* joking, joking!  Matter of days, promise... if you’re still interested that is...?  and where are you points going btw?

Title: Chapter 13 27 Jan 2010 11:46 pm
Reviewer: severitusfan4ever (Signed) [Report This]
    GREAT CHAPTER!!!! yipee! ummmm... well, I liked the sentence,

    "He unfroze a little inside when he detected very faint movement – Harry was breathing – but it was shallow and slow and, placing an icy hand over Harry’s forehead Severus failed to understand how it could possibly feel colder than the snow around them."

    I thought it was sweet and so.. everything I want in Snape!!! Poor, poor, Harry. Update soooooon please!

    Author's Response:

    Aww thank you!  Sweet Sev and Hopeless (but Helpable) Harry coming up ^-^ and have some muffins and fifteen points too ^-^

    Have fun!

Title: Chapter 13 20 Jan 2010 12:36 pm
Reviewer: wrappedinharry (Signed) [Report This]
    This chapter was so, so brilliant! Well done you.

    ***Unlike the night before, Harry found he was suddenly hyperaware of everything for a brief moment and felt filled with dread and fear and a childlike anxiety that gripped his stomach in a tight fist before leaving him feeling completely empty. He felt more numb than ever and he didn’t think he was really thinking straight as he watched with a vague kind of attentiveness as Umbridge slid a piece of parchment across the desk to him, the rasp of paper on wood loud in the otherwise silent room. Her voice slithered past any defences he may have had and transcended his thoughts and feelings like a thick, pernicious smog, trying to find and suffocate the life and freedom from him. And for every second it invaded him and tore him down, Harry found he couldn’t quite keep up; as though he had only a few seconds of memory before a thought or feeling was lost.***

    The above is just one example of how wonderfully descriptive your writing is as far as Harry's feeling go. I could hilight so many more passages, but i would end up putting most of the chapter in the review panel!

    That woman deserves nothing less than the Dementor's kiss, but I have a horrible feeling she will be able to wheedle her way out of serious trouble, at least for a while. When they find out what happened to HArry... come to think of it, how long will that be? HArry, when he regains consciousness and realises where he is and remembers what has happened to him, will no doubt not tell anyone the truth... will say he ahd an accident.

    And when they do find out that Umbridge is responsible, will Fudge come down on her side and prevent justice being done? The possibilities are nauseating.

    DD's anger will be formidable, once he is over the fear that Harry will die. Minerva too. All of them, even Snape would be truly appalled with Harry's torture and that it has gone on for so long without anyone being the wiser.

    And Sirius... wow, the possibilities are endless of what you can come up with to horrify us further. And hopefully, the newly free Severus will play a major part. As this is P&S, it is certain he will.

    Can't wait for more, Lisa. This was brilliant, but I think I have already said this. I am so looking forward to more (think I have said this too).

    Lesley~

    Author's Response:

    So many reviews and such kind compliments!!! *blushes and never stops smiling ever again ^^*

    Hehe, aww, you’re so very very sweet ^^ - I hope I can keep writing to the standard you seem to like, isn’t it awesome when people like something that you’ve put so much thought into?  *sighs and grins ridiculously hugely* *have a gleeful muffin... they smile a lot too ^^*

    Of all things I didn’t consider giving Umbridge The Kiss... it always seemed such a peaceful, passive kind of punishment for all that it was a horrifying experience that led to a slow death via wasting away... it just seems a little anti-climactic though, dontcha think?  No, need something a little more... satisfying... when it comes to Umbridge.  Come on, really, so many people think she won’t get hers but I ask you, if I could think of all of that to put Harry through when he hasn’t done anything wrong, would I really let Umbridge off with a kiss?  Even if it was from Mouldy himself it wouldn’t be enough... no, I’m working on something with many layers of horror for the toad... (I did so love her punishment in one fic I read... eaten as a toad by kitty McGonagall... hopefully I can be so inventive ^^)

    And have no fear, when Harry wakes we’ll be beyond the point of his excuses being believed.  That’s one thing I’ve been able to do for my severely irritated readers ^-^

    And as Dumbles will explain in ch15, Fudge – though not involved just yet – is seriously unlikely to be on Umbridge’s side in any of this (*coughupcomingelectioncough*)

    Hehe, I find it interesting, the way you said that – ‘even Snape’ – hmm... you’ll see... surprising how people change in times of stress (though hopefully believably... ?  hope you let me know *bites nails*)

    Oh, no doubt about that though, Sev will play an enormous part don’t worry bout that ^^ - and I’m still working with Sirius on his reactions... for all his immaturity, his volatility is so much fun to write! ^^

    Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU.  You never leave me feeling underappreciated that’s for sure! *muffins galore for you!!!!*...*and more!!!!!!!!*

    ...

    ...

    ... *and more!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!* ^^ and perhaps and update too...? ^^

Title: Chapter 13 20 Jan 2010 2:16 am
Reviewer: jenny-in-uk (Signed) [Report This]
    Excellent, more please? Just playing catch-up with feedback but really impressed. Good writing style too.

    Author's Response: Thank you! More soon, promise ^^
Title: Chapter 13 19 Jan 2010 11:57 pm
Reviewer: Chandramas (Signed) [Report This]
    4 days... it's too early for nagging for a new chapter? I can't wait for Severus reaction to Harry's abuse from Umbrige! I thing I'll cook some Popcorn and watch the show :p

    Author's Response:

    oh, four days isn’t too early at all but I think you’d be a bit angry with me if you had sent a review every four days... sorry, this wait cant have been fun if you were antsy so soon – not long now, have your popcorn ready ^-^ - *hands you blueberry muffins* ^^

Title: Chapter 13 19 Jan 2010 8:37 pm
Reviewer: Fmh (Signed) [Report This]
    Great chapter as always loved the "When did the brat become the boy and Potter become Harry".
    Hoped Severus would catch Umbridge at her foul work and hex her but I'm keeping fingers and toes crossed he still does! Thank you for updating

    Author's Response:

    Thank you!  And I do so love that bit as well ^^ - I think without it the next chapter wouldn’t have become what it is so I’m glad you liked it! And thank you so so much for an awesome idea you gave me... I hadn’t planned things the way you were hoping this story would progress but just know that if Harry goes to Umbridge (you’ll know what I mean if I can include it) then it stems from this review because it put the idea in my head of confrontations ^^ (and I don’t mean the one in two chapters time  either ^^ - you may have just altered the path of this fic, thanks! ^^)


Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5