|
Reviews For When the Boat Comes In
Author's Response: Thanks :) I thought that Severus would use psycological punishments; in the canon, he only very rarely resorts to physical violence, preferring to zap his students with acidic insults. Therefore, stripping Petunia of that which she values most would probably be a more appealing revenge and, besides, it gets Dudley out of Privet Drive and into a environment where he can learn to be a decent and disciplined person.
Author's Response: Thanks ^^: I thought it'd be more Severus's style to inflict psychological punishments.
Author's Response: Lol, well, he had been placed under a spell which, literally, made him walk a mile in Harry's shoes- albiet in his dreams. Once Dudley had been in Harry's place, he, naturally, realised that no child deserved how Harry had been treated and, therefore, decided that his mother was a terrible person. Something similar happened in the canon, when Harry rescued Dudley from the Dementors: Dudley certainly gained respect and a degree of affection for Harry, as evinced by his behaviour at the beginning of Deathly Hallows. The reason why Dudley's behavior is so much more extreme here is 1. the abuse has been more severe, 2. Dudley is younger (ie. more impressionable) and 3. he has seen life at Privet Drive from a 'Harry's eye view'. Author's Response: Lol, well, he had been placed under a spell which, literally, made him walk a mile in Harry's shoes- albiet in his dreams. Once Dudley had been in Harry's place, he, naturally, realised that no child deserved how Harry had been treated and, therefore, decided that his mother was a terrible person. Something similar happened in the canon, when Harry rescued Dudley from the Dementors: Dudley certainly gained respect and a degree of affection for Harry, as evinced by his behaviour at the beginning of Deathly Hallows. The reason why Dudley's behavior is so much more extreme here is 1. the abuse has been more severe, 2. Dudley is younger (ie. more impressionable) and 3. he has seen life at Privet Drive from a 'Harry's eye view'.
Great chapter! Author's Response: I thought about that but, considering how much Petunia loves and idolises Dudley, it feels like it would be far more effective to make him go through the torments- in his dreams- and wake up reviling her. It's sort of like the difference between having a life-threatening illness yourself and watching someone you love dying; if it's you who is ill, you can bully yourself into keeping your spirits up whereas, if it's someone you love, their pain will cause you an anguish which you cannot reason away. Think about Lily's plea to the Dark Lord "Not Harry, please no, take me, kill me instead"; she would rather die herself than watch her baby killed and I think that, for Petunia, knowing that Dudley had suffered, albeit for one night, what Harry had suffered, would be far worse than if she was subjected to the experience for every day of the rest of her life.
Author's Response: Thanks ^^ I'm glad you approve on my style of justice lol!
Author's Response: Thanks ^^ I thought so too.
I just have one question, did Dudley really not notice anything going on? I know he is only 11, but after Vernon died didnt Dudley notice how mean his mom was to Harry? Or did he truly believe that Harry deserved it? Or maybe Petunia really did threaten him too? I dunno, anyway just curious. Author's Response: Dudley did know what was happening to Harry but he had been indoctrinated by his mother to believe that Harry was a freak who deserved whatever he got. It takes a bright, inquiring mind to look at the situation in which one has lived all their lives and think 'this is not right because of a, b and c' and Dudley just doesn't have that type of mind; In the cannon, Dudley accepts it when Harry is locked in a cupboard, starved, emotionally abused and treated as a slave and, indeed, endorses and aids his parents neglect by beating Harry up and frightening away potential friends. In this fic, Dudley 'sees the light' and, like many people who suddenly find themselves complicit in abuse, he pretends that he knew all along that what was happening was wrong but was too scared to speak out. Thanks for the compliments; I'm really glad you like the idea of Hermione being in Slytherin. In the canon, we see the Slyths from an outsider and aggressor's point of view. Although it is arguable that some of the Slyths would not have developed into nice people whatever the circumstances, there is a degree of self-fulfilling prophesy: Harry is told that Slytherins are evil, backstabbing bastards and, because he treats them with suspicion and contempt, they act like evil, backstabbing bastards. However, from a friendly, insider's point of view, the Slyths are going to show the nice sides of their characters and, with the softening influence of Harry and Hermione, could develop very differently. |
Powered by eFiction 3.5 |