Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For The Summer of '89
Title: Chapter 1: Fickle Caprice 03 Mar 2011 6:16 am
Reviewer: Min (Anonymous) [Report This]
    GReat job!

    Author's Response: Thanks!
Title: Chapter 2: Hope It's Not Contagious 03 Mar 2011 1:59 am
Reviewer: Pandora (Signed) [Report This]
    Harry sounds so cute.

    Good story Lia. Looking forward to next chapter.

    Author's Response:

    Thanks Pandora. I had tips from Wands to change the way Harry sounded - though I still think that he needs to stop being so confrontational with Ron. Also, I think he's a bit too mercurial. 

    Before the next chap, I need to reedit this chap and include more dialogue. I am delighted to hear that u were able to read thru the chap - it's so boring right now.

    Thanks so much for leaving a review. Do continue to leave your suggestions and comments behind.

    Lia 

Title: Chapter 1: Fickle Caprice 03 Mar 2011 1:48 am
Reviewer: Pandora (Signed) [Report This]
    Good start Lia.

    Will we get to find out more about how Snape got custody of Harry, and why he calls him "Uncle"?

    Those twins are incorrigible! LOL! Imagine making their house disappear!

    Onto the next chappie. Good work.

    Author's Response:

    Hey Pandora,

    Thanks for leaving chap-wise reviews.

    I myself wd have to think abt the custody thing. As far as 'Uncle' is concerned, Harry's not Snape's son and so, calls him Uncle. He is used to that.

    Poor twins - flattening themselves was really bad! Hope they learn to find out more about their experiments before actually doing them the next time. It's a dangerous and stupid thing.

    Thanks again for leaving a review.

    Lia 

Title: Chapter 2: Hope It's Not Contagious 03 Mar 2011 12:58 am
Reviewer: Morgana (Signed) [Report This]
    Another great chapter; loved how Severus deals with the boys, especially his conversation with jealous little Harry. Looking forward to reading more

    Author's Response:

    Thanks again Morgana! You made it thru the chappie? It's a nightmare with so little dialogue and no partitions. Need to reedit it.

    I am glad you liked the conversation between Harry and Snape. I was really not sue abt it - thought that it sounded too forced and not at all natural.

     

    Thanks again, Morgana! 

Title: Chapter 2: Hope It's Not Contagious 02 Mar 2011 10:46 pm
Reviewer: graynavarre (Signed) [Report This]
    This is lovely - poor Harry, he never had to share Severus and now he does.

    No wonder he is acting up.

    Author's Response:

    Thanks graynavare.

    I thought to show him a little clingy, therefore, Snape deciding on the attic cleaning so that Ron didn't feel left out. Snape is in as tricky a situation where he has been saddled with a child and can't even act out for the fear of influencing Harry negatively. Harry and Snape's summer routine has changed along with Ron's.

    Glad u cd read thru the chap, it badly needs some more dialogue to break up the monotonous long stretches of paragraphs. Wd have to rewrite it, I guess!

    Thanks a load for leaving a review,

    Lia 

Title: Chapter 1: Fickle Caprice 02 Mar 2011 8:40 pm
Reviewer: Morgana (Signed) [Report This]
    Lovely chapter; I really like this premise- I can see how easily Fred and George could do something that silly (given their inventive streak). Ron's feelings are brilliantly portrayed (you've captured his character perfectly) and his arguement with Harry felt very realistic. I also love your depiction of Severus; he's not quite the canon Severus (he wouldn't be after 4 yrs of fatherhood) but he has many of 'canon-Snape's' characteristics. Well written and entertaining

    Author's Response:

    Hey Morgana,

    Thanks so much! I keep finding mistakes and problems and wishing to change it all the time so the compliments are really confidence boosting. I am extremely bad with writing kids and i owe a lot to my beta as well, Wands. See, that reminds me, I need to put in the disclaimer and Thanks to beta! I am glad you found the chapter entertaining :)

    Also, I had pretty much given up on Snape halfway through the fic. His most defining point is his irascible nature, at least towards kids and that has gone for a toss here. I tried to inculcate a little sarcasm, but I don't do it well and lost subtlety somewhere during the flow as also, downplayed his language. So, I am really glad to hear that this character could be rationalised to be a new-and-improved Snape somehow. I had given up hope.

    Thanks for leaving a review once again.

    Lia 

     

Title: Chapter 2: Hope It's Not Contagious 02 Mar 2011 8:27 pm
Reviewer: AchillesMonkey (Anonymous) [Report This]
    This is really good. I'd love to learn the background, how Harry and Snape became Uncle and nephew and how Sirius is free.

    Author's Response:

    Hi Achilles,

     Umm... I am not sure how much of the background I'ld be able to bring in - maybe, over a period of time,  if I could manage it. The challenge just said that Harry and Ron are both under Snape's guardianship, temporary or otherwise, and that Snape must not be a spy. For Snape not to be a spy, I decided that the war is over and Snape was clearly on the side of Light, Snape, therefore, kept some contact with Lily and Pettigrew was captured. So, Sirius is free. I would have to think up the details.. hmm..... I was more worried abt Ron coming under Snape's guardianship this time.

     

    Thanks for the review. I did not want to submit, thnking that the 2nd chapter is really long and dreary....  glad you liked it. Even gladder that you left a review.

    Thanks,

    Lia 

Title: Chapter 2: Hope It's Not Contagious 02 Mar 2011 8:15 pm
Reviewer: Sita Z (Signed) [Report This]
    I'm really enjoying this so far. Your description of nine-year-old Ron and Harry is very realistic, tantrums and jealousy and fighting over sand bridges included. I also like your patient and mature Snape, and I had a good laugh over the annoying alarm clock - I'd lock it in a drawer at bedtime!
    I'll admit I was a little surprised that Snape took the boys to church; I'd imagine wizarding culture would distance itself from Christianity, what with the difficult history between them. That's just a minor point though, I really like the story and I'm looking forward to more!
    Sita

    Author's Response:

    Thanks Sita Z,

    I am so delighted to hear that the description of Ron and Harry came through as realistic. I was pretty sure that both of them were sounding much oder than themselves, while Snape's vocabulary had shrunk down to mine. I do have to thank my beta, Wands for this, who took out the time to offer suggestions despite being busy managing the fic fest.

    The alarm clock ... hmmm.... I think that Snape sets it at night when he comes to check on the boys before retiring for the night. He has to get his quota of entertainment from torturing someone! And really, don't blame my poor Lolly! The poor thing has to wake up all night keeping time so that it could wake up a sleepyhead at 8 a.m. and the longer the sleepy head sleeps, the longer Lolly's night shift extends. He is sleepy and just wants to go to sleep but can't till Ron wakes up. ;) It just wants Snape to tuck him in as well in the morning and a little lullaby in that glorious voice won't hurt! :)

    About the church thing - it is an ode to Harry's muggle heritage. If Snape ever takes in Harry, it would be for Lily's sake and I wd imagine him trying to raise him the way Lily might have wanted to. Also, the books celebrate Christmas and the weddings are in the same style so I assume that the wizards have the same religions as muggles, specially the ones as old as Christianity/Judaism/Islam/etc. They could have a separation from Church but then, they would have come up with a church of their own.

    But well, it could go either ways. Given that Harry is a half-blood, I decided that he shd know a little of muggle culture and Ron being a Weasley, cd only be encouraged by his parents. But it cd be either ways.

    Wow! my response is longer than your review. :)

    I am glad to hear that u cd read thru the enture 2nd chapter cus it's quite chunky and does not have any dialogue in between. I need to change the structuring of the chapter, or else, break it up into smaller chapters for easier reading.

    Thanks a zillion times for leaving a review,

    Lia 

     


Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5