Summary: There's always been one thing that I have wondered about Harry Potter and that is - was Umbridge truly good? Or did she work for Voldemort? If so, why did she punish Harry so firmly? Wouldn't she have been happy to hear from her old master? Or is there something else sinister in the midst?

If she is actually good then why does she have such dark implements as a blood quill, and why would she use them?

Must have Snape discover Umbridge's punishment of Harry.

Any category, however bonus points if a Father category.
[Report This]