Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For Lily's Charm
Title: Chapter 22: Finding the Words 08 Jan 2008 8:41 am
Reviewer: lyra (Signed) [Report This]
    ::whimpers pathetically::

    But, but you stopped *there*! I've been waiting so long to for Harry to call him Dad and now I have to wait for the reaction!

    *grins*
    Brilliant cliffhanger. Brutal, but brilliant.

    Author's Response: Well, thank you!  Brutal, but brillian, indeed.  LOL  I had to stop there, didn't I?  Couldn't give you too many warm fuzzies (or maybe angst) in one chapter now could I?  What fun would that be?  Hopefully, you'll like the reaction just as much.  Thanks for review.  Glad you liked my cliffie!  :o)
Title: Chapter 22: Finding the Words 08 Jan 2008 7:20 am
Reviewer: KimSpiritTalks (Signed) [Report This]
    Awesome! He called him Dad! I love it! I can't wait for Snape's response. This is great. I'm so glad you're one of the ones who update frequently. I would expire waiting for this next chapter if you kept us waiting too long.

    Remus was fantastic in helping Harry see that Snape had feelings, too. I loved how Harry was SOOO Harry when he raced to the floo to go to Remus to see him before he left. That was just right. As always, an excellent chapter.

    Author's Response:

    Thanks!  I'm glad you liked the dad part.  Sev's resonse is up next.  LOL  'expire' while you wait.  Well, you won't have to wait too long.  The next chapter will be up in a few days hopefully.  I always say that and then wonder if maybe this will be the chapter that takes forever.  LOL  I'll do my best though.

    I love Remus, don't you?  He's just great.  And, yeah, I like to keep Harry, pretty Harry-ish.  I love that crazy Gryffindor! 

Title: Chapter 22: Finding the Words 08 Jan 2008 4:53 am
Reviewer: Polaris (Signed) [Report This]
    I was laughing in that last bit and then got quite emotional when Harry actually said it! Aah, what a beautiful word. I love that it's out there, I can't wait to see Severus's response!

    What an interesting day for them. They're all so conflicted, like Remus tending to defer to Severus now before he answers him, and then hesitating to act like a guardian of some sort. Oh the angst! I love it.

    I could just picture Harry grinning like a loon after Severus's little rant to him, even though he was sitting down to have a serious conversation about the war. Sounds about right.

    I find myself trying to piece together the cause and effect of all the actions in this story and how they differ from canon. Particularly in this chapter, I was thinking about how Severus's marriage to Lilly would have affected his role as Death Eater and in turn his relationship with Malfoy. And then how Lucius knows his status as a spy and Narcissa does not come to him for help with protecting Draco. Is this because in canon, Lucius does not suspect Severus but Narcissa does and therefore goes to him for help, whereas in your universe, Lucius is in the know? It's interesting, I love all this 'a butterfly flaps its wings...' stuff.

    Are you including Horcruxes in this story? Dumbledore doesn't have his withered hand in this one does he? Unless I'm recalling wrong. Anyway, that shall change things a little, hopefully he doesn't have to be killed at all!

    I am a Stephenie Meyer's fan, though very recent. I finished Eclipse last week and it's such a fantastic story. I like how she lists her musical influences, it's quite interesting. I can't believe that you listened to that song the whole time, I like the song but I think I would have grown sick of it. Unless you're superfast at writing chapters or something.

    Speaking of, love the fast updates! I hope you continue to stay inspired for this story because it's so much fun to read! By the way, are we going to get anymore flashbacks? They're quite fun sometimes! Perhaps Severus will recall happier times when Harry called him 'Daddy' freely. I love those old sweet scenes. Anyway, take care!

    Author's Response:

    LOL  Why can my reader alway read my mind?  There is a flashback coming up next chapter.  Either I'm really good or really bad that my readers always guess what's coming. :o

    I too love that it's 'out there' now.  It was such a slow trip to get there but finally!  Yay.  I too can't wait to see what Severus will have to say. LOL

    Angst!  I love angst.  And, yeah, they're all pretty much twisted up in tenuous knots, aren't they?

    Remus doesn't quite know what to do with himself, though he is trying.  But, we knew he would.  He's too great not to!

    LOL about Harry grinning while he's about to have a talk about Voldemort.  It just seems so Harry.

    I love cause and effect and really, I was trying to combine things in a way I would hav preferred them in books six and seven (well, and include Harry and Snape as father and son...lol) so that's where really all of this came from.  His relationship is very important to this story, and yes very different than it would have been in canon.  But, don't forget that I didn't mention how long Malfoy has known about this business and trust me, that is vital to this plot.  (LOL, I know I'm annoying, eh?  Can't resist though)  And, yeah Narcissa sending Lucius to talk to Severus is different but all will be explained yesterday.  I too really love how things will shift and change just from one simple change.  I love AU fics for this reason, but especially the ones that at least follow some of canon but twist it around.  And, nope, there is no withered hand here!  No more hints, though!  LOL

    I didn't really love Eclipse because...well, I hate  Jacob!  But, I won't get into that here.  LOL  I know that could get heated.  ;o)  Oh, and yeah, I did listen to the same song the whole time, but my machine wouldn't work with repeat for awhile and so everytime it would switch to the next song, I got so distracted I coudn't even write!  LOL  I'm crazy, it's true.  

    Thanks for the review! 

     

Title: Chapter 22: Finding the Words 08 Jan 2008 2:45 am
Reviewer: cathyrf (Signed) [Report This]
    My internet connection was down for half the day and when I finally get it working again, this awaits me. It's good to be me! (And even better after having the heater repairman fixed my broken furnace this morning which had been dead all weekend...it was damn cold in my house! It's 40 degrees outside! And my fingers were much too cold to produce more artwork).

    I just had a funny (delightful) feeling that the chapter would finish up on the note that it did, especially after Remus' comments to Harry. Applause to Harry for being a courageous Gryffindor! What I can't WAIT to find out is Severus reaction to Harry calling him "Dad." I suspect he might just give himself a case of whiplash.

    Poor exasperated Remus having to deal (yet in his usual understanding manner) with a panicky Harry. And having Snape explode in his apartment AT Harry while he nonchalently makes tea...what a guy. A big ol' hug for you, Remus.

    And I could just totally hear Alan Rickman's voice in my head in his rant at Harry. And this part:

    "You are my son. Nothing is going to change that…no matter how many times you give me the urge to throttle you.”

    How do two sentences move me to tears and make me laugh out loud all at the same time? (How do you DO that?) But Harry has never had a parental figure that cares, so it doesn't surprise me that it will take quite a bit of time (and Severus never faulting ONCE in his concern, not that I expect he would at this point but I truly think Harry needs time to believe) for it to sink in for the poor kid.

    THANK YOU for clueing Harry in on at least SOME vital information. And Draco's plight...wow. You might make me actually care about him in this fic when I rarely do in others. If anybody can, it will be you. ;-)

    Author's Response:

    First of all...sorry about your cruddy weekend and no heat!  And worse, no internet!  Oh, I would die!!  LOL (and darn your cold fingers...am I gonna get my Remus eventually, though?)

    Second of all, as per usual, I just want to give you a big chapter 20 Harry/Severus hug!  You always make me grin and feel like I might have some idea what I'm doing in this big old world of fanfiction, after all.  LOL

    Yes,a case of whiplash might be in order, although you never know with that tricky so and so.  :o)  

    I loved Remus so much in this chapter.  Just the right amount of caring concern and stern lecturing.  I really love that werewolf.  (hint...hint...picture..hint LOL)  And, making tea...well, the guy did use 'his father' when talking to Harry, so he has to show some sort of acceptance of it, doesn't he?  And, I just SEE Remus as basically nonchalant so that was no surprise.  

    I love that you could hear Alan Rickman shouting at Harry.  Now, that rant was really fun to write.  LOL  And picturing Harry cringing but not really in the usual fear of Snape was fun in my head.  Again, darnit, wish I could draw but it's good that I can't because I would never write anymore. 

    More {{hugs}} for you, lady!  I don't know how I make you both laugh and cry, but man I'm glad I can.  :oP  And, yeah, Harry needs to let it all sink in, and a lot of that will depend how Sev reacts now that Harry has put himself out there.  And, you're welcome for letting Harry in, but you really should thank Sev.  LOL  Oh, yes...please do care about poor Draco.  That kid is beside himself!  Mabye Harry can actually start caring too.  LOL

    Thanks for another awesome review!  Glad you're day's going better.  :o) 

     

Title: Chapter 22: Finding the Words 08 Jan 2008 12:16 am
Reviewer: Kristeh (Signed) [Report This]
    Well, I'm glad that things went better than I'd expected for Harry and Severus. I'm also really glad that Severus flat out told Harry he wouldn't abandon him or reject him again. I know Harry needs that reassurance.

    It's good that the adults are letting Harry know some of what's going on, too. That was a big part of why Harry went to the Dept. of Mysteries, which of course led to Sirius' death. Not that I'm placing any blame on Harry for it, or even Dumbledore. They may have made mistakes, but they did the best they could. I say Bellatrix and Voldemort are squarely to blame.

    Anyway, I'm looking forward to the next chapter!

    Author's Response:

    Harry does need that reassurance.  I don't know if you read my reply to a review a few reviews back but the part I wrote last chapter about Severus thinking how Harry was acting the way Lupin and Albus had said he would...well, I explained that and I think it explains too why Sev said it.  Anyways, in case you were interested.  :oP

    LOL  Yes, Bellatrix and Voldemort are pretty much to blame for that.  But, it definitely would have helped if Harry hadn't been in the dark so much.

    Thanks for reviewing.  Glad you're still enjoying! 

Title: Chapter 22: Finding the Words 08 Jan 2008 12:08 am
Reviewer: Phoenix1 (Signed) [Report This]
    Well Snape did say he could use the title so why not "DAD".

    Author's Response: LOL  He did say that, didn't he?  We'll have to wait to see what Snape thinks now.  :oP

Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5