Potions and Snitches
Snape and Harry Gen Fanfiction Archive

Reviews For Slave Child
Title: Chapter 23 24 Feb 2022 6:37 pm
Reviewer: MeAndNotYou1001 (Signed) [Report This]
    I'm not ill.
    ...
    You know, it's really sad how often mental illness is ignored. Of course he doesn't actively know better (even if deep down he knows this is not what he should be doing, what with him avoiding his friends and all) but even in the real world it's ignored.
    It sucks. A healthy mind is as important, or even more, as a healthy body.
Title: Chapter 23 29 Jul 2008 6:38 am
Reviewer: Anne Squires (Anonymous) [Report This]
    It's hard for me to read these letters because they remind me very much of the suicide letter of someone who was close to me. He succeeded in killing himself. January 19, 1979. I'm crying. I'm not kidding, crying. You are pumping deep feelings here. I'll just say that the letters are very realistic. I think I've been putting off reading your story for a while because suicidal themes can make me... uncomfortable. Angry, scared, sad, extremely emotional. I'm just remembering and experiencing old memories and feelings that are difficult. I always fluctuate between anger at the person who killed himself and feeling sorrow for him. On the one hand I feel that he was cowardly and selfish to do what he did. On the other hand I think he was brave and depressed, sick. Brave because I think that when it comes right down to actually committing the act it takes a lot of bravery to go through with it. And sick because a person must be very ill to get to that point. A psychiatrist told me once that God does not punish people for killing themselves because they are depressed and depression is an illness like cancer is an illness. Just as God doesn't punish people for dying of cancer, he doesn't punish people for dying of depression.

    You are very talented to get inside of the head of a suicidal person like this. It's so real. At the same time it doesn't seem gratuitous or exploitive any any way.

    You are extremely talented to be able to evoke so much.

    Author's Response:

    Hi, Anne,

    I feel like I should apologise almost. I can only imagine how painful that must have been for you. I love reading your comments, can definitely understand you wanting to keep some distance, if you need to. What a terrible thing for a family to have to go through.

    I know that so far Harry has been seeing suicide as a solution to his problems, but he will come to see that he was wrong, that if he had he would have denied himself the joy of having his most cherished dream come true. I hope that if people will read SC and the sequel to the ends, they will be satisfied with how it turns out (or mostly anyway. I know you can't always please everyone). But I do hope the story will ultimately be life-affirming and can show a message that there is always hope and that life can always get better, no matter how hard it may be for a time.

    I do think that a person who commits suicide is ill, because depression and hopelessness are an illness. I have never been suicidal, but about ten years ago, I did go through a fairly severe depression when someone close to me died, and it really took over a year before I healed. Even though I never went so far as to contemplate suicide, I remember the hopelessness, the fatigue, the feeling of being overwhelmed by little ordinary things, and worst of all, the feeling that no one could help. I suppose I'm drawing on that when I portray Hrry and his feelings now.

    Thank you very much!

Title: Chapter 23 23 Jul 2008 11:29 pm
Reviewer: footontheground (Signed) [Report This]
    Great job! I can't wait to see how Severus finds out what Harry is up to!

    Author's Response: Thank you!  I'll try to update again soon! 
Title: Chapter 23 22 Jul 2008 1:25 pm
Reviewer: ankita (Anonymous) [Report This]
    the letters were perfect!!! i mean the way they conveyed harry's feelings is really great...i was wondering why isn't there any letter for remus??
    as always waiting for the next chapter

    Author's Response:

    Thank you! Well, I debated about including a letter to Remus, and I didn't for a couple reasons.  One...I felt like I had to draw the line somewhere.  If Harry had written to Remus, then he would have needed to write to Dumbledore, maybe Poppy, and when I was writing I already wasn't sure if I were taking up too much time with the letters and had decided not to actually show the one to Hermione which really would have been more important than one to Remus and DD, imho. 

    But also, at this point, I'm not sure how close Harry and Remus actually are.  I think Harry wants to be close to Remus, but it isn't just quite there.  Remus has been pretty absent from Harry's life for the past two years, after all.  I think Remus has his own issues with closeness, which will be mentioned later on in the fic, and this is what has caused him to pull away a bit, but for now, Harry isn't sure at all how Remus feels about him.  He thinks Remus may well blame him for Sirius' death and might not want to hear from Harry.

    I'll try to update again soon. 

      



    Author's Response:

    Thank you! Well, I debated about including a letter to Remus, and I didn't for a couple reasons.  One...I felt like I had to draw the line somewhere.  If Harry had written to Remus, then he would have needed to write to Dumbledore, maybe Poppy, and when I was writing I already wasn't sure if I were taking up too much time with the letters and had decided not to actually show the one to Hermione which really would have been more important than one to Remus and DD, imho. 

    But also, at this point, I'm not sure how close Harry and Remus actually are.  I think Harry wants to be close to Remus, but it isn't just quite there.  Remus has been pretty absent from Harry's life for the past two years, after all.  I think Remus has his own issues with closeness, which will be mentioned later on in the fic, and this is what has caused him to pull away a bit, but for now, Harry isn't sure at all how Remus feels about him.  He thinks Remus may well blame him for Sirius' death and might not want to hear from Harry.

    I'll try to update again soon. 

      

Title: Chapter 23 22 Jul 2008 12:59 pm
Reviewer: Jess (Anonymous) [Report This]
    Excellent chapter...

    It's always hard to know where to start with someone who has failed a suicide attempt.. Even when you've been suicidal yourself. You're doing a fantastic job showing Harry's mindset as he is suicidal.

    I saw in your other reviews you've had major computer problems. I know the pain. My laptop corrupted my entire thesis about a week and a half ago. That was painful. (I still defended on time, though.) I can totally relate.

    Author's Response: Thank you!  Yes, Severus is going to have to do the best he can, and all the while he'll wonder if he's doing and saying the right things.  I'm sorry about your computer problems; I can definitely commiserate.  Glad you were able to pull it together in time. 
Title: Chapter 23 22 Jul 2008 11:24 am
Reviewer: crazychick84 (Signed) [Report This]
    aww he just gets more cute with every angsty chapter! those letters were so heartfelt, you really make it sound like Harry really wants to die, bless him! as always looking forward to more

    Author's Response: Thank you!  Well, at the moment, Harry does want to die, or at least he thinks he does.  Severus has to convince him that his life is worth living now.
Title: Chapter 23 22 Jul 2008 8:36 am
Reviewer: Polaris (Signed) [Report This]
    Oh noes! I can't believe you've left us here, knowing what Harry is about to do. I think including what was in the letters was good. It gave an insight into how Harry sees his relationships with his friends and Severus. Best of luck with the next chapter, can't wait!

    Author's Response: Thank you!  I'll try to update again soon!
Title: Chapter 23 22 Jul 2008 5:49 am
Reviewer: xoAngelicDemise (Signed) [Report This]
    Fantastic chapter! As usual!

    Author's Response: Thank you!
Title: Chapter 23 22 Jul 2008 3:49 am
Reviewer: sunsethill (Signed) [Report This]
    The letters are some of the best writing in this story so far, IMHO. They hit on exactly the points that would be important to Harry, but which he is incapable of expressing normally. I especially loved the one to the Weasleys, with Harry remembering how much it meant to him to have Molly and Bill show up before the last task. And yet, you see so clearly that though he thinks of them as some kind of family, it's not real in his heart. Severus has so much work to do!

    Author's Response:

    Thank you!  I enjoyed writing the letters because they are a look at Harry's truest emotions...things he would not ordinarily be able to say, but which he feels deeply, like you said.  I thought Harry would have been really touched by Molly and Bill coming to the tournament that time. I was really touched by it when I was reading.  It was one of those little scenes that really mean a lot.  You can understand so clearly how hard it is for Harry not to have a family of his own, when the other three champions all have theirs come to cheer them on and offer support.  You see again how badly the Dursleys have failed Harry.  And for Molly and Bill to come and be his family...welll, if I hadn't already been in love with the Weasleys, I would have been at that point.

    And yes, much as Harry loves the Weasleys, he doesn't understand the depth of their feelings and he doesn't really believe that anyone is his.  Severus does have his work cut out for him. 

Title: Chapter 23 22 Jul 2008 3:31 am
Reviewer: graynavarre (Signed) [Report This]
    Severus is going to have a "cow"

    Author's Response: Thank you!  LOL, he certainly will!

Disclaimer Charm: Harry Potter and all related works including movie stills belong to J.K. Rowling, Scholastic, Warner Bros, and Bloomsbury. Used without permission. No copyright infringement is intended. No money is being made off of this site. All fanfiction and fanart are the property of the individual writers and artists represented on this site and do not represent the views and opinions of the Webmistress.

Powered by eFiction 3.5