Good chapter, I had already been looking forward to it! But cruel: cruel of you to stop here (!) and cruel of Snape to ask Harry such a question! If I were Harry, I would answer that I would consider falling down a cliff, being sure of one's death and getting injured punishment enough! However, I somehow doubt that Snape would agree... poor Harry! Please update as soon as you can!
Author's Response: Yes, but Snape has never dealt with this kind of issue before. I agree it's ill advised--but he's making an effort not to turn into Tobias.
And he was actually sort of good about helping Harry with the nightmare. So I'd give him a B+, all things considered.