Wow!!! I absolutely loved this chapter! Harry's internal conflict resolved through music and memory -- awesome! And Snape's declaration at the end was priceless. 😁 I couldn't figure out what was "missing", but the explanation via George was excellent. I kind of wish that Harry could've had a sense of closure when George died, but we don't always get that, do we? Life and death are fickle, and one can interrupt the other unexpectedly, leaving a gap that is difficult to fulfill. I feel, however, that Harry achieved his closure at long last during the concert. Wish I'd been a fly on the wall of the Great Hall! Thank you!
Beautiful! I loved George. And also loved the vision of Harry, garbed in cast offs, standing on stage letting his music transcend it all.
Aww this fic was so sweet, I loved the premise even before I read it but your story was amazing! I was listening to both songs in the background the whole time and that just made it for me, the ending was just beautiful and your setup and background for it was great. Now I’m probably going to scour the internet for other good music HP fic’s, so thankyou for introducing me to this idea and for your amazing story!
Author's Response: hey there, sorry it took too long to reply to your wonderful review; thank you so much for the support and i have some good news for you in case you haven't found any musical HP fics, i'm working on a musical sequel for this fic, and i will start updating as soon as my other work Start of time is finished :) stay tuned Random Human!
Oh god, this was so beautiful. I got a tingling sensation in my stomach and goosebumps on my hands I had always wanted to play the piano but this story gave me so much more reason to play. Music is Magic, I had always known this fact but you proved it.I know you said that this story is finished but what happened with George? What does Dumbledore know about it? I made an account on this website just to review this story, it was very beautiful, beautiful beyond words, I became so frustrated with Harry's denial that I skipped to the end and slowly worked my way up, literally.
Author's Response: thank you sooo much lucinda! i'm really happy that my story inspired you to play a musical instrument, and yes music is magic! about the ending...i was considering writing a cool humor/musical sequel if i end up with the right plot (probably soon) so things will be explained in the sequel, although i will eagerly answer any questions you have;)
and can i take a moment to tell you how cool you are and how flattered i am right now?!! wow! /you/ registered in the site just to review on my works, i'm seriously dancing with joy ;) yes, i was frustrated with Harry too, to the point that i wrote this chapter simultaneously with another story so i wouldn't end up blowing it!
Title: Chapter 2
| 12 Aug 2017 9:15 pm
|
Reviewer: Fmh (Signed)
| [Report This]
|
Wonderful story with so much emotion thank you so much
Author's Response: Thank you for reading, your wonderful reviews warms my heart Fmh ;)
Title: Chapter 1
| 26 Jul 2017 9:43 pm
|
Reviewer: Fmh (Signed)
| [Report This]
|
Loved the story and George of course thank you
George!!!! Noo!!!!
Author's Response: i know right? thank you for the review lily ;)
Mr Lightwood was a bit of a mystery - a wizard or a squib maybe? It will be interesting to see how you link this with Hogwarts and Snape.
Author's Response: he certainly is, i loved writing him. i'm eager to upload the next chapter too! thank you rosina ;)
|