Membership status: Member
|
|
| My Pet:
|
Penname:
| trust severus spy [Contact]
| Better be Alumni!
|
Call me:
| LK Darling (undisclosed)
| Member since: 21 Apr 2008
|
Beta?
| Yes
|
|
About me:
|
|
| Happily married for 20 years, this coming October. Two lovely daughters, four lovely grandkids. I always knew Snape was the most interesting character in the series! I love good writing, especially with good spelling and good grammar. [Report This]
|
Find me:
|
|
|
|
Your ability to show Harry's vulnerability, Severus' protectiveness, and Poppy's professional caring is just wonderful. What a well-written chapter. I look forward to seeing how Harry's relationship with Severus progresses. Thanks for all your work!
Author's Response: You're welcome. *said shyly*
Aww. I'm glad Harry could read without having been taught; it's a sign of keen intelligence. I'm more interested in how Albus (as 'Brian') will interact with Ariana. That's a unique situation you've set up here, quite interesting. Good chapter; thanks for all your work.
Author's Response: O' course, then there was me . . . and I didn't really learn how to read until age 7. lol
Absolutely wonderful! As delightful as the tea and cookies, eh, BISCUITS Harry and his daddy enjoyed after that class. Good work!
This was quite a story. Strangely enough, I found it realistic and believable for a piece set in a fantasy world. Not the usual bouts of foolish wand waving, just the slower, more natural magic of healing through work, good intent, and love. Quite nicely done. Thank you.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. I kind of like Severus healing without the aid of magic simply because it was magic that damaged him his whole life. I would think that he needs a little rest after what he went through. T
Rated: K+
-
Warnings: Profanity
Chapters: 1
-
Completed: Yes
-
Updated: 11 Jul 2010 / 11 Jul 2010
Series: None
-
Challenges: Death Walk
I liked this story; I generally like it when Severus and Harry finally reach some kind of mutual positive understanding. You did a nice job, especially the line 'It took more bravery than any Gryffindor in the history of Hogwarts to play the role of double agent so well,' as it's so true.
My one suggestion would be that lines 12 & 13 be combined, as all the dialog before and after those lines are alternating speakers. Although it's Harry saying both those lines, we initially think it's Snape saying "Which brings me back...I didn't want you to die." 'Huh? Oh--it's still HARRY', we think to ourselves. As readers, we stumble, since you've got the separate line AND the separate quotes, which is why we don't realize it's Harry still speaking. Move "Which brings me back..." to the previous line right after "Oh wait, you can't because you're dead," and the story will be perfect. A "10" for you.
Author's Response: im so glad you like my story. and thanks for catching that mistake for me! i didn't even notice it. i fixed it now.
Severus Snape is a spy by nature and by training. As such it infuriates him when he realizes that he knows virtually nothing about the real Harry…other than the fact that Harry keeps a journal. Using his own invisibility cloak, Severus sneaks into the Gryffindor tower while the students are at the leaving feast and exchanges the journal's specially matched ever-sharp quill with a quill of his own that has been charmed to a parchment in Severus' possession so that everything Harry writes is copied to the parchment. What does Harry write, and what happens when Severus realizes that they are kindred spirits. 2010 Challenge Fest entry. Response to Pen Pals by dianehc.
Takes Place: 4th summer
-
Snape flavour: None
Tags: None
Categories: Fic Fests > #11 Challenge Fest 2010, Snape Equal Status to Harry > Foes Snape and Harry, Teacher Snape > Professor Snape
Rated: T
-
Warnings: Abusive Dursleys
Chapters: 1
-
Completed: Yes
-
Updated: 13 Jul 2010 / 13 Jul 2010
Series: None
-
Challenges: Pen Pals
I really liked this. I'm going to "favorite" it as soon as I've finished this review. Snape as protective dark angel is one of my favorite images of him. Very nicely done. Thank you.
I enjoyed this story, and wish there were more of it. But how can Draco call him Snape, and apparently not know who he is, teenager or not? I don't understand why he couldn't have been "Robert O'Reilly", and the new name explained in a sentence or two at the beginning; there are other stories here that do it, and it works. You've got Snape's POV showing us Sev's experience as an adult thrust into a body half his mental age. You show very well how much more intimidating Draco and his goons are, when one's physically more their size, rather than larger. Since we can see how threatening the three younger Slytherins are--and they know this is a Snape--why don't they realize it's their old head of house? You told the story well, otherwise.
The end? Surely you've got to be kidding. You don't do an elaborate setup, with Draco and Snape involving Harry and a whole summer in front of them, only to let it drop out of your fingers and fall on the floor, then say "the end!" No, this is a first chapter, and a rather good one at that. Keep going!! Here's a "10", to encourage you!
Author's Response: I'm just floored at the response of this story. I never expected it. Okay, I'll write more. You've convinced me! Thanks for the review.
This was good. You cranked up the angst-meter, and got it going. Well done: I wept for them both. Thanks for a story well done. A new favorite for my list. Thank you.
What delightful lyrics to 'Hush Little Baby', which I would guess to be PD (in the Public Domain, or beyond copyright, and therefore free). Charming!
|